This show featured the Phish debut of Petrichor and the debuts of Home and More. Page dedicated Home to his mother who was in attendance at the show. DWD contained a NMINML tease from Trey and was unfinished. Cities featured Trey on Marimba Lumina. Mike teased Petrichor in Hood.

Photo © Rene Huemer

Noteworthy Jams
Teases
Petrichor tease in Harry Hood, No Men In No Man's Land tease in Down with Disease
Debut Years (Average: 1999)

This show was part of the "2016 Fall Tour"

Show Reviews

, attached to 2016-10-14

Review by TimPhishMit

TimPhishMit The wife and I rolled up into the parking lot around 4pm. We had just driven into town from Charlotte and everything was fun in the car with no bumps in the road, pun intended. Due to Hurricane Matthew, our original beach cabin we had booked in Isle of Palms was flooded and we had to look for a residence elsewhere. We got luckier than we ever could have planned because we scored a mansion of a home on AirBnB owned by a very sweet woman, and the price was only $133 a night, which was the same cost if or even less for the Sleep Inn! Now we were feeling like things were looking really up and we were truly blessed.

After food shopping for some groceries and settling in for about an hour or so at the mansion, we were parked in the lot the E3 post and we were ready to get rolling! Bust out the cooler, pop the champagne bottle, we are making some tropical mimosas, and boy were they tasty. My wife went to one show in the past in Atlanta and it wasn’t really her thing, but I had been spending a nice amount of time leading up to these two shows making her mixes of studio tracks and giving her Big Boat and she was really coming around more than I even expected. I’ve been seeing the band since 2011 and these two Charleston shows were going to be numbers 6 and 7. This was my wife’s first true experience taking it all in the right way, meaning the lot and Shakedown Street and making the whole weekend a true Phish Event. Shakedown delivered on its universal promises of being the best place to chill and look at cool stuff while drinking a tasty beverage in hand. My wife told me I just HAD TO buy some Trey socks so I did, and I went ahead and bought my buddy back home a pair of Page Side Rage Side socks since I know he was pretty bummed he couldn’t make it out for the shows like he would have liked. I had been telling my wife for weeks now that I was gonna be buying her a heady lot shirt for her to rock on night II so she could partake even more so in the festivities; well we found some cool Charlotte folks that had some of my favorites shirts I found on the lot in terms of originality and quality of shirt itself, so my wife now owns an awesome Halley’s Comet shirt that reads Treys Antipasto with a cool image on the front, and now whenever she is in line at the grocery store everybody behind her will reading about Cadillac Rainbows and how much she loves meatballs (funny, maybe they’ll all look for the meatballs in her food cart). Myself, I was just about to walk away with the same shirt in a different color, but then remembered they had an amazing “Phall Tour” shirt with shadowy figures of the boys and some awesome different colored leaves, so I decided to get that one instead and not cramp on Wifey’s style. The breeze was just right and we got our eats in by way of some great little bite size steak tacos with homemade aioli and an incredibly tasty chicken wrap that we were able to split. After speaking to some awesome crystal folks about all the different rocks they had on display (my mouth dropped with some of the rocks I saw on their table), it was time to pack up the car, make sure we had the tickets, quickly follow that dude that said he would take me to the guy who was secretly selling Heady Toppers (he was, but he ran out, and I was able to get my hands on the last Focal Banger IPA), let my wife run into the lobby bathroom of the hotel next to the Coliseum, and head into the show!

My wife seemed to be having a really great time and I was so pumped up and ready for my first opening gig of tour and first indoor Phish show, so I couldn’t have been in any better spirits walking into that place (One side note: walking around the coliseum is fun because there are some other convention-type buildings around it and it totally feels like you are back on your college campus). I was wondering how it was going to work with all these GA seats, and it was awesome for us because we walked right down to maybe 3 or 4 rows from the floor and found 2 seats that were open and we sat with a cool group of guys from Augusta (if you’re reading this Raymond and Andrew and crew, it was a pleasure and a blast). I’ve never seen the band so close before since I typically do the lawn during summer tour because of the easy ticket price and the fun vibe, so this night was going to be a whole new deal. I was ready to get down and dirty.

SET ONE:

PETRICHOR – This was an incredible move by the band, and listening back to the show the morning after, they played every note perfect. To open the Fall Tour with this number, considering the different opinions on the new album (I’m one of those who loves Big Boat) and the fact that Chucktown just got hit by Hurricane Matthew a week ago, this was the ballsy move and I loved it. Petrichor is the Big Boat song that has gotten the most repeated listens in my 93’ Buick Regal named Kramer, and I thought it was a very high achievement for the band but didn’t know if we would get to hear it live for a real long time because of how it might translate in a live setting; would it kill the vibe in the 4th quarter, or would it work somewhere? Well, the boys came out with guns blazing and they killed everyone in the venue with two to the chest. It’s worth mentioning that the last section of the song, “And the rain came downnnn”, that’s the section they stretched out to play around with and it worked. Also worth mentioning that the crowd really got down when the song changed up to the funky section earlier in the song. It’s cool they played it, and I’m glad to have the Phish debut under my belt.

GHOST – Great placement in the 2-slot. After the huge deafening applause post-Petrichor, hearing Trey play the Ghost riff with the whole coliseum in the dark with no lights, we were already to blast off in this spaceship together. The jam was Type-I and it was sweet and crunchy, which honestly is exactly what a Ghost is expected to do in Set I: deliver the goods and get the crowd in the right frame of mind. Thank you, Ghost!

HEAVY THINGS – I’m one of the crowd who enjoys a nice Heavy Things, and the band had a little extra gusto with this one. When people listen back to the show, I think they will enjoy it because it just seemed like the right song to play. We just got blasted with a great new big composed monster to open the show, followed by taking us back to the funk with Ghost? Let’s all throw our arms around each other and sing about Vanessa and Mary!

HOME – Home is a song I enjoy, but also a song I was willing to use as an opportunity to grab another beverage and use the restroom. I was able to hear it pretty well even though I left the seats (another plus of seeing the band at an indoor venue) and it sounded like it rocked. Listening back to the show, it pretty much stays in the lane that you’re familiar with from the album. Cool thing I didn’t catch Page say before playing the song, his mom was in the crowd and he said hello and dedicated the song to her. I’m guessing his parents live in Charleston since his dad was up on stage with the band back in 2010, the band’s last visit to the city.

POOR HEART – I rolled back to the seats just in time to catch this number start. The song is standard and what we all come to expect, but I have fun with it. Who doesn’t like dancing to a lil’ diddy when the mood is right on the first night of tour?!

BATHTUB GIN – I was very happy to hear this come out in Set I. It could truly come out anywhere and I would be very happy, but getting Ghost and Gin in the first set is usual a sign of a STRONG first set, and this set was working out its muscles right now. It wasn’t anything earth-shattering at the show, but again, it’s Gin and it’s always good when mixed just right. Listening back, I really like Gordo’s playing in this version, so keep the ears open for that if you are looking for some meaty bass playing.

555 – I am a big fan of this song; it’s probably in my top three favorite songs off of Fuego, and I think it’s a great Gordo song. My big issue with this song is I really think it has the ability to be a HUGE jam vehicle and for whatever reasons the band has, they don’t seem to want to do much more with the song at the moment. When they opened up Set II of 07/25/2014 in Charlotte with this song, my hopes got so high just to be shot down. PLEASE GUYS!! TAKE THIS SONG TO NEW PLACES!! Nonetheless, always a welcome song for me.

HORN – This was a good time and a nice treat. Never got a Horn before. I’m not looking at the song’s history, but it seems that it’s pretty sporadic with where it pops up in a show, so I enjoyed myself. It’s a good straight-up rock tune and it’s good to have that in the later half of the set to keep the vibe on the up-and-up.

MORE – I was surprised the band decided to play More here. I think we can all agree that we heard this song on the album and collectively thought, “Oh, this song is cheesy, but it sounds like it will be a lot of fun live and work perfect in the encore slot”. Well, they decided to use it to close out the first set instead. I don’t want to sound like a party pooper, because I will definitely be listening back to this whole show a lot and enjoy it all thoroughly; I am just being nit-picky now, but I think I can think of other songs I would rather have in the last song of the set. So, all in all, it was cool and it was a nice finish, I just think the song might transcend itself more in the encore slot of a fantastic show.

SET ONE SUMMARY: This was a GREAT opening set of tour and when Fall Tour is over, I think we all agree that we could tell how great the tour was going to be by how the band delivered here. Fired up, not willing to take chances, and looking to share the vibes with the responding crowd in the city rocked by the hurricane.

SET TWO:

NMINML – The boys got right into it with this song to open up SET II. I think it works well for getting the crowd going right away, so I like it for that. And to be honest, sometimes I don’t know what my personal feelings are on this song regarding if I’m a big fan or not, because since they’ve debuted last summer around the same time, I’m more of the Blaze On guy; funny, I always think of those two songs together because of Summer Tour 2015. I usually think of the song as a great song to blast off into a more serious jam, but just a pretty straightforward funk song on its own. At this show, the song revealed itself to me as not just a place to jump into the stratosphere from, but a good song on its own to get the crowd going out of the gate. Cheers to that, and an even bigger cheers to what came next…

DOWN WITH DISEASE – Honestly, now that we are in the 3.0 era, when are we not excited to get a DWD in the early part of Set II??? I could listen to that DWD guitar lick we all love and know so well ALL DAY EVERY DAY and it will always succeed in getting me pumped for what is to come out of it. For me, that guitar lick is one of the trademark musical sections of this band. Kudos to the two guys behind me who were singing “NMINML” with me when we both had fun realizing we both heard the same tease at the same time. DWD is always a good time, but what hit next was probably what I will remember most from this show on a very personal note…

CITIES – MY FIRST CITIES. I could try to express my love of Phish’s take on this Talking Heads song and the way it gives me the down-and-dirty-southern-Charleston-covered-in-grits-feel that I love oh so much, but I don’t have to because we all feel the same way collectively. At the 8-minute mark of DWD, the band slows things down and gets sludgy for all 13,000 of us in the coliseum and this awesome dirty jam led into the tasty-like-gravy segue (and I mean legit segue, none of that “song stops and Fishman plays on his hi-hat a little bit while we go into the start of the next song” crap). This Cities is slow baby, and it fits perfectly with Charleston and what we were all wanting down in the south for this Fall Tour. Raymond from Augusta hugged me and thanked me for this because I spoke to him earlier about how much I would love a Cities since I have yet to catch one. I hope y’all all enjoy Gordo and Trey’s Bass/Marimba Lumina battle as much as I did! Think of Charleston, small city… well, on this night, the coliseum felt like we were our own city and Philadelphia had nothing on our brotherly love. And I love Elvis, so thank you Elvis for bringing your spirit down for this one!

ROGGAE – I’ve always enjoyed this song. In my head, I tend to pair this song together with Limb By Limb because they are both chill and not super heavy or loud fast, but perfectly fitting to follow up after that great molasses that came before. Always a pleaser for me if it is placed in an appropriate spot, and it was at this show.

TWENTY YEARS LATER – I view this as the curveball they pitched tonight, and I liked it. The song is cool, no monster or anything, but I think we can all love the fact that Twenty Years Later is our breather of the set, am I right?! “Hey man, it could’ve been The Line, so I’ll take it!” ;D

LIGHT – Light was GREAT tonight. I feel the song has two sides to it: it can either meander with its usual Lighty-self and the next thing we know we are in the next song and we look back and see it was just filler. Then we have the Lights we love so much that blast us off into outer space and land us on the moon; we dance around as hard as we can until that one guy grabs the American flag that was placed there so many years ago, you know, that one we weren’t supposed to touch?! He waves it around and runs around like a mad man and we then find ourselves just cheering him on because he had the balls to do it. That was last night’s Light. Have fun with the NMINML tease that begin at the 7:30 min mark. The jam they play with at 10:40 in is the jam we heard somewhere earlier this summer. I can’t remember which it is, but my gut is saying maybe the Ghost LOCKN? I could very easily be wrong, but it is from one of the jams I loved most in Summer 2016.

FREE – Who is dumb enough to ever say that they didn’t want to hear Free? I had my arms wide open and up in the air and I was taking in every minute of it, making sure I didn’t miss my chances to yell “FREEEEEEE”. I always enjoy the breakdown, always enjoy Gordo slapping my ass, oops I mean his bass.

BOOGIE ON REGGAE WOMAN – YES YES YES PLEASE OH YES DO NOT STOP. GIVE IT TO ME HARDER. ( I enjoyed myself)

HARRY HOOD – For the sake of time since we want to get going to an aquarium around the area before tonight’s sequel, let me just say that I always feel good about Hood and this set just reminded me of that important part of life.

SET TWO SUMMARY – One for the books people. This book will be place on my shelf at a spot that is easily accessible for me to grab whenever needed. Y’all down here will never see no dust on this book!
PLEASE, READ THE BOOK!!!!

PS – For the encore talk, we stayed part wat into Winterqueen but I didn’t feel the need to stay and believed I had my fill and was ready for heading out the doors. I got back to our place and saw that they had played Tube and Rocky Top after WQ, and thought “Man, I would’ve stayed if the encore was Tube>Rocky Top!” I love those tunes, but honestly, it’s all good everybody, I got all the amazing memories I could handle on the first night of Fall Tour in Chucktown. Also, we went to Wafflehouse after the show and I had a blast there eating an amazing hashbrown bowlwith scrambled eggs and sausage. Ronya at Waffle House was wonderful and she gave me my hash browns the way she likes them, so I was calling it the Ronya Special Hashbrown Bowl. People work so hard at that joint man, I love sitting at the bar and watching them put the food together. After seeing a great Phish show and appreciating people and life, the Wafflehouse was a wonderful experience that transcended what a normal Wafflehouse experience is to an everyday visitor.

The P-Fish – changing Waffle Houses everywhere, one tour stop at a time.

- Timbo
, attached to 2016-10-14

Review by humalupa

humalupa This was solid for a tour opener, and would be a solid show at any placement within a tour. The first set, especially up through Gin, was engaging, with the well-played debut of Petrichor in the first slot, followed by an enjoyable Ghost that poked at the margins of type-II jamming. Home sounded great live, especially Trey's warm, Brian May-esque lead lines, and I'd welcome this one again, for sure. Gin built to a nice peak as it's wont to do these days. Horn was nicely place, but had some unfortunate sloppiness in the solo. I was hoping for Bowie of the like to close the set, and More seemed like an odd choice. It contains potential for powerful rocking, so we'll see where it goes in the future; maybe it can establish itself as a closer in its own right.

Set II was phenomenal, and I enjoyed every minute of it. To me, the cohesiveness that gelled at Dick's carried through, with the band quickly finding its way into type-II territory early on in DWD, and executing a legitimately great segue into Cities. I wished the jam in Cities extended past Trey's drumming, but Page's playing during this section was the real highlight, as he powered through sticky and nasty clavinet playing. Roggae was above-average (as it has been for a couple years now), with particularly memorable Trey solo peak. Light kicked things up again, and concluded with multiple sections of true hose jamming that were simply top-notch. Free and Boogie kept things moving and maintained the forward momentum, and Hood performed exactly as intended, putting a nice exclamation on a set that was cohesive and of-a-piece moreso than it was a collection of songs.

Winterqueen was a weird choice for the encore, but the Tube that followed quickly erased any doubts regarding Trey's thought process. Check this one out, as it reaches some brief but interesting type-II moments. Rocky Top rounded things out on an energetic note, and sent us smiling toward the exits.

I'm still not sure whether they broke curfew (the following night finished up noticeably earlier), but the result is three solid hours of great, engaging playing, with an inspired setlist. The show is definitely worth a full listen and/or purchase, and to me, it earns an easy four stars, as it was well-above average throughout.
, attached to 2016-10-14

Review by fhqwhgads

fhqwhgads Woo-hoo, Fall Tour! Petrichor is a great choice for an opener, IMO. It's captivating to hear it flower live, whereas before I had only heard Phish's studio version--none of Trey's orchestral versions found their way to me. Easy to imagine it going the way of Time Turns Elastic, but I am a hearty supporter of that composed epic, too! Ghost rates high on the average-great scale for me; no machine-gun Trey or such as that but it builds to a nice peak. Page's lead section in Heavy Things is particularly energized, perhaps by--as he annotates at the end--the presence of his mom at the show. Home seems built for live performances, really sounds natural in this context. Gin, like Ghost earlier in the set, "rates high on the average-great scale for me." Satisfying peak, though nothing particularly ground-breaking, in this moveable feast of virtuosity that we perhaps sometimes take for granted, i.e. Phish shows. More also blossoms onstage, and fits in very well as a set-closer. It has a bit of a Show-of-Life vibe to it in its wistful reflection, although the song structure itself may lend itself to future explorations.

No Men's really takes us on a ride, with some full-steam-ahead rocking jamming during its (relatively) brief (or concise) 8 minutes and 42 seconds. I don't think this song is gonna be shelved anytime soon, so I eagerly anticipate some truly deep ventures. The segue from a slightly above standard DWD into Cities is remarkable, IMO! And the Cities itself is remarkable for approaching 10 minutes in length and for featuring some textural magic from Trey on Fish's Marimba Lumina. Not much to say about Roggae, Twenty Years Later, but Light reaches some really interesting polyrhythmic grooving. Some unusual occurrences in the Hood intro, though the Hood itself is again (déjà vu all over again) a solid average-great. Winterqueen might've been nearly a Friday-worthy encore choice if not followed by a somewhat extended and groovy Tube and a rollicking Rocky Top. Some skew on the rating here, and if half- or quarter-stars were available it'd be different, but I don't feel remiss in rating this tour opener a 4 (really more like a 3.5) partly just due to the overall excitement of having a happy, healthy Phish fresh off a new album with--arguably--something to prove.
, attached to 2016-10-14

Review by Phisherman39z

Phisherman39z Man, did I enjoy this show. Some of my friends had asked me to take them to a show after years of talking about the band. They saw the SPAC webcast since I was present, and they liked what they saw/heard. Anyways, it was 2 first timers and 1 at his second show. They surrendered, and after talking about it with their wives, now even the ladies want to go to a show.

Loved Petrichor. Floor was talking up a storm, but then again, people are free to do what they want. I thought it was quite ambitious for the band to come out with that on N1 of the fall tour. That being said, I like a fast paced song to kick things off, and it seemed that some in the crowd didn't recognize it. In fact, I was asked by a few people standing around me which song was being played. Oh well.

Ghost is a favorite of man, and I'll never complain when they played. Crowd really picked it up from there on out.
Heavy Things on the other hand is definitely not a favorite of mind. Bathroom break for me after quite a few beers.

As far as Big Boat is concerned, I like it. Petrichor, Home, More, IAWITW are all great. It was nice to hear Page dedicate Home to his mom that was in attendance. Again, some around me didn't recognize it. I implored them to listen to the new album, hopefully they listened.

Who doesn't like Bathtub Gin. Phish is unlike anything out there, and my buddies were astonished at the entire crowd yelling that Bath line. The crowd never disappoints.

555, always good for me. I really like that song. Horn! I was never expecting that one, and finally More. I really like this song; I know the lyrics are cheesy, but trust me folks, the outro jam has legs.

Second set...now we're talking. Pure funk in NMINML, Cities, and Roggae. DWD is another favorite of mine, and I've been blessed to see 2 of the finest (Miami Disease and Dicks Disease). Again, nothing special here, but it's a crowd favorite. I'd say that was the meat of the second set, NMINML>DWD->Cities>Roggae. Definitely worth a relisten.

The guys seem to really like Light, as it consistently produces a solid jam. Boogie On was a freaking blast, and it really got the crowd into a dance fest. And to end with Harry Hood. It was a very solid Set II if you ask me.

Winterqueen, meh. Like Heavy Things, not one of my favorites, but the Tube and Rocky Top definitely made up for it.

Last word...I know the more entrenched fan has given the album a listen, but for the love of all things Holy...listen to the album.
, attached to 2016-10-14

Review by wookieegroove

wookieegroove My first show! In my hometown. Couldn't have asked for a better intro into becoming a Phan. Grew up a Deadhead. Saw Trey play at Fare Thee Well. Gained so much respect for him and his musical capabilities.
That coupled with listening to Big Cypress over and over, I couldn't get enough. When Fall '16 was announced, I went nuts! To open in my backyard; are you kidding me?!
Drove up from Walterboro about an hour away. Jammed Wrigley the entire ride. Met my buddy in the lot and it was on from there. Immediately met some incredible people/lifelong friends. Managed to scout great seats 3 rows up from the pit. Such an incredible vibe just taking in the entire experience.
Debuting Petrichor was awesome. Then, came Ghost and I was blown away. Not to mention a killer Gin; which is my favorite song! And, an insane DWD into a "dance party" Cities!
I apologize for sounding like a newb, but man was it a time to be had by all! It took me by horns and I am forever grateful.
There is no band that throws it down like PHISH!
Thank you so much for everything!
Justin
, attached to 2016-10-14

Review by cmg348

cmg348 This is a show that'll likely get lost in the shuffle in the long run, but that was extremely enjoyable live and will play back well, too, I suspect. The new songs were played with tremendous gusto, and Petrichor, to open, was a ballsy - and very true-to-form - move that in my opinion really paid off. I'm looking forward to hearing it again and to seeing it get stretched out a bit as well. DwD, though short, gets into some awesome, hard-edged action before a super slick segue into a sharp Cities. Light is all over the place, but without feeling unfocused - a strong jam filled with interesting ideas. Generally, even though there's no one jam that will enter any pantheons, there really isn't a low point to speak of here. Excellent tour opener.
, attached to 2016-10-14

Review by julius54

julius54 Fall tour got off to a hot start on Friday night. Coming right out of the gate with Petrichor, and they nailed it. I loved it on the album and it was even better live. People are gonna come around on this one. First set Ghost was first set Ghost--type one and crunchy as hell--definitely worth a listen. Heavy Things settled us down as Leo took over for a fun little jam. I really like Home on the album and was looking forward to hearing it. Felt a little flat though, but still enjoyed it--the end was worth it. My first Poor Heart, awesome. Gin coming in hot and a good time was had by all. 555 and Horn your standard first set songs, did the job they were supposed to do. I really, really disliked More on the album--felt like an OAR track to me--but damn was it good live. Still sounds like a TAB song to me though more than Phish.

No Mens was a superbly funky start to set two. They didn't take it as far as I'd hoped but the DWD that followed did the job. Trey was bouncing all over the place on this one, very fun. Cities! The first timer I brought with me loved this. Trey moving to the Marimba was awesome. If you were on the floor, you could feel the vibrations shaking your ribcage. Roggae was a nice slow down. 20YL I can do without. Light was great as usual. Free pretty standard, but still raging. Boogie On>Hood was a spectacular end to a great show.

Winterqueen, Tube and Rocky Top. Who could've guessed that combo? Weird but fun end to the show. Had a great time, the south knows how to party.
, attached to 2016-10-14

Review by oklahoma

oklahoma MEATBALLS wrote the worst review I have ever read. That is saying something for this site! Must have never gotten enough love from his/her creative writing teacher. Haha!

First set was fun and I'm always open to hearing new material even if the band is still working some kinks out. Second set was absolute fire! Overall a fantastic start to the tour.
, attached to 2016-10-14

Review by julius54

julius54 Fall tour got off to a hot start on Friday night. Coming right out of the gate with Petrichor, and they nailed it. I loved it on the album and it was even better live. People are gonna come around on this one. First set Ghost was first set Ghost--type one and crunchy as hell--definitely worth a listen. Heavy Things settled us down as Leo took over for a fun little jam. I really like Home on the album and was looking forward to hearing it. Felt a little flat though, but still enjoyed it--the end was worth it. My first Poor Heart, awesome. Gin coming in hot and a good time was had by all. 555 and Horn your standard first set songs, did the job they were supposed to do. I really, really disliked More on the album--felt like an OAR track to me--but damn was it good live. Still sounds like a TAB song to me though more than Phish.

No Mens was a superbly funky start to set two. They didn't take it as far as I'd hoped but the DWD that followed did the job. Trey was bouncing all over the place on this one, very fun. Cities! The first timer I brought with me loved this. Trey moving to the Marimba was awesome. If you were on the floor, you could feel the vibrations shaking your ribcage. Roggae was a nice slow down. 20YL I can do without. Light was great as usual. Free pretty standard, but still raging. Boogie On>Hood was a spectacular end to a great show.

Winterqueen, Tube and Rocky Top. Who could've guessed that combo? Weird but fun end to the show. Had a great time, the south knows how to party.
, attached to 2016-10-14

Review by gigrant

gigrant Petrichor was a cool way to start Fall Tour. The Ghost that followed had great soloing, perhaps the finest moment of the night for me. Good first set. 555 remains one of my fav Mike songs and I would be happy to hear it at every show.

Set 2 had it's moments too. NMINML had everyone shaking a leg, and DwD is always welcome. Trey was really bouncing around during the solo, and the seque into Cities was a great idea. I was up front for this show, behind some nice girls who were against the rail, and when the Lumina fired up at the end of Cities I almost fell out. It was deep and powerful, notes that hit you right in the chest. I recommend not standing in front of that speaker. Actually, the whole mix from there was subpar compared to the rest of the floor because the overhead speakers where behind me. But it's always fun being close so who cares. Free was great. Strong performance. Boogie On sounded muddy (Mike's bass effect) but it may have been my positioning. I will re-listen later today. Rocky Top was fun.

Good show. The floor wasn't too crowded so dancing was on the menu, the people were super nice (southern hospitality??), and the lot scene was respectable. I hope everyone had as much fun as I did.
, attached to 2016-10-14

Review by gigrant

gigrant Petrichor was a cool way to start Fall Tour. The Ghost that followed had great soloing, perhaps the finest moment of the night for me. Good first set. 555 remains one of my fav Mike songs and I would be happy to hear it at every show.

Set 2 had it's moments too. NMINML had everyone shaking a leg, and DwD is always welcome. Trey was really bouncing around during the solo, and the seque into Cities was a great idea. I was up front for this show, behind some nice girls who were against the rail, and when the Lumina fired up at the end of Cities I almost fell out. It was deep and powerful, notes that hit you right in the chest. I recommend not standing in front of that speaker. Actually, the whole mix from there was subpar compared to the rest of the floor because the overhead speakers where behind me. But it's always fun being close so who cares. Free was great. Strong performance. Boogie On sounded muddy (Mike's bass effect) but it may have been my positioning. I will re-listen later today. Rocky Top was fun.

Good show. The floor wasn't too crowded so dancing was on the menu, the people were super nice (southern hospitality??), and the lot scene was respectable. I hope everyone had as much fun as I did.
, attached to 2016-10-14

Review by TimPhishMit

TimPhishMit The wife and I rolled up into the parking lot around 4pm. We had just driven into town from Charlotte and everything was fun in the car with no bumps in the road, pun intended. Due to Hurricane Matthew, our original beach cabin we had booked in Isle of Palms was flooded and we had to look for a residence elsewhere. We got luckier than we ever could have planned because we scored a mansion of a home on AirBnB owned by a very sweet woman, and the price was only $133 a night, which was the same cost if or even less for the Sleep Inn! Now we were feeling like things were looking really up and we were truly blessed.

After food shopping for some groceries and settling in for about an hour or so at the mansion, we were parked in the lot the E3 post and we were ready to get rolling! Bust out the cooler, pop the champagne bottle, we are making some tropical mimosas, and boy were they tasty. My wife went to one show in the past in Atlanta and it wasn’t really her thing, but I had been spending a nice amount of time leading up to these two shows making her mixes of studio tracks and giving her Big Boat and she was really coming around more than I even expected. I’ve been seeing the band since 2011 and these two Charleston shows were going to be numbers 6 and 7. This was my wife’s first true experience taking it all in the right way, meaning the lot and Shakedown Street and making the whole weekend a true Phish Event. Shakedown delivered on its universal promises of being the best place to chill and look at cool stuff while drinking a tasty beverage in hand. My wife told me I just HAD TO buy some Trey socks so I did, and I went ahead and bought my buddy back home a pair of Page Side Rage Side socks since I know he was pretty bummed he couldn’t make it out for the shows like he would have liked. I had been telling my wife for weeks now that I was gonna be buying her a heady lot shirt for her to rock on night II so she could partake even more so in the festivities; well we found some cool Charlotte folks that had some of my favorites shirts I found on the lot in terms of originality and quality of shirt itself, so my wife now owns an awesome Halley’s Comet shirt that reads Treys Antipasto with a cool image on the front, and now whenever she is in line at the grocery store everybody behind her will reading about Cadillac Rainbows and how much she loves meatballs (funny, maybe they’ll all look for the meatballs in her food cart). Myself, I was just about to walk away with the same shirt in a different color, but then remembered they had an amazing “Phall Tour” shirt with shadowy figures of the boys and some awesome different colored leaves, so I decided to get that one instead and not cramp on Wifey’s style. The breeze was just right and we got our eats in by way of some great little bite size steak tacos with homemade aioli and an incredibly tasty chicken wrap that we were able to split. After speaking to some awesome crystal folks about all the different rocks they had on display (my mouth dropped with some of the rocks I saw on their table), it was time to pack up the car, make sure we had the tickets, quickly follow that dude that said he would take me to the guy who was secretly selling Heady Toppers (he was, but he ran out, and I was able to get my hands on the last Focal Banger IPA), let my wife run into the lobby bathroom of the hotel next to the Coliseum, and head into the show!

My wife seemed to be having a really great time and I was so pumped up and ready for my first opening gig of tour and first indoor Phish show, so I couldn’t have been in any better spirits walking into that place (One side note: walking around the coliseum is fun because there are some other convention-type buildings around it and it totally feels like you are back on your college campus). I was wondering how it was going to work with all these GA seats, and it was awesome for us because we walked right down to maybe 3 or 4 rows from the floor and found 2 seats that were open and we sat with a cool group of guys from Augusta (if you’re reading this Raymond and Andrew and crew, it was a pleasure and a blast). I’ve never seen the band so close before since I typically do the lawn during summer tour because of the easy ticket price and the fun vibe, so this night was going to be a whole new deal. I was ready to get down and dirty.

SET ONE:

PETRICHOR – This was an incredible move by the band, and listening back to the show the morning after, they played every note perfect. To open the Fall Tour with this number, considering the different opinions on the new album (I’m one of those who loves Big Boat) and the fact that Chucktown just got hit by Hurricane Matthew a week ago, this was the ballsy move and I loved it. Petrichor is the Big Boat song that has gotten the most repeated listens in my 93’ Buick Regal named Kramer, and I thought it was a very high achievement for the band but didn’t know if we would get to hear it live for a real long time because of how it might translate in a live setting; would it kill the vibe in the 4th quarter, or would it work somewhere? Well, the boys came out with guns blazing and they killed everyone in the venue with two to the chest. It’s worth mentioning that the last section of the song, “And the rain came downnnn”, that’s the section they stretched out to play around with and it worked. Also worth mentioning that the crowd really got down when the song changed up to the funky section earlier in the song. It’s cool they played it, and I’m glad to have the Phish debut under my belt.

GHOST – Great placement in the 2-slot. After the huge deafening applause post-Petrichor, hearing Trey play the Ghost riff with the whole coliseum in the dark with no lights, we were already to blast off in this spaceship together. The jam was Type-I and it was sweet and crunchy, which honestly is exactly what a Ghost is expected to do in Set I: deliver the goods and get the crowd in the right frame of mind. Thank you, Ghost!

HEAVY THINGS – I’m one of the crowd who enjoys a nice Heavy Things, and the band had a little extra gusto with this one. When people listen back to the show, I think they will enjoy it because it just seemed like the right song to play. We just got blasted with a great new big composed monster to open the show, followed by taking us back to the funk with Ghost? Let’s all throw our arms around each other and sing about Vanessa and Mary!

HOME – Home is a song I enjoy, but also a song I was willing to use as an opportunity to grab another beverage and use the restroom. I was able to hear it pretty well even though I left the seats (another plus of seeing the band at an indoor venue) and it sounded like it rocked. Listening back to the show, it pretty much stays in the lane that you’re familiar with from the album. Cool thing I didn’t catch Page say before playing the song, his mom was in the crowd and he said hello and dedicated the song to her. I’m guessing his parents live in Charleston since his dad was up on stage with the band back in 2010, the band’s last visit to the city.

POOR HEART – I rolled back to the seats just in time to catch this number start. The song is standard and what we all come to expect, but I have fun with it. Who doesn’t like dancing to a lil’ diddy when the mood is right on the first night of tour?!

BATHTUB GIN – I was very happy to hear this come out in Set I. It could truly come out anywhere and I would be very happy, but getting Ghost and Gin in the first set is usual a sign of a STRONG first set, and this set was working out its muscles right now. It wasn’t anything earth-shattering at the show, but again, it’s Gin and it’s always good when mixed just right. Listening back, I really like Gordo’s playing in this version, so keep the ears open for that if you are looking for some meaty bass playing.

555 – I am a big fan of this song; it’s probably in my top three favorite songs off of Fuego, and I think it’s a great Gordo song. My big issue with this song is I really think it has the ability to be a HUGE jam vehicle and for whatever reasons the band has, they don’t seem to want to do much more with the song at the moment. When they opened up Set II of 07/25/2014 in Charlotte with this song, my hopes got so high just to be shot down. PLEASE GUYS!! TAKE THIS SONG TO NEW PLACES!! Nonetheless, always a welcome song for me.

HORN – This was a good time and a nice treat. Never got a Horn before. I’m not looking at the song’s history, but it seems that it’s pretty sporadic with where it pops up in a show, so I enjoyed myself. It’s a good straight-up rock tune and it’s good to have that in the later half of the set to keep the vibe on the up-and-up.

MORE – I was surprised the band decided to play More here. I think we can all agree that we heard this song on the album and collectively thought, “Oh, this song is cheesy, but it sounds like it will be a lot of fun live and work perfect in the encore slot”. Well, they decided to use it to close out the first set instead. I don’t want to sound like a party pooper, because I will definitely be listening back to this whole show a lot and enjoy it all thoroughly; I am just being nit-picky now, but I think I can think of other songs I would rather have in the last song of the set. So, all in all, it was cool and it was a nice finish, I just think the song might transcend itself more in the encore slot of a fantastic show.

SET ONE SUMMARY: This was a GREAT opening set of tour and when Fall Tour is over, I think we all agree that we could tell how great the tour was going to be by how the band delivered here. Fired up, not willing to take chances, and looking to share the vibes with the responding crowd in the city rocked by the hurricane.

SET TWO:

NMINML – The boys got right into it with this song to open up SET II. I think it works well for getting the crowd going right away, so I like it for that. And to be honest, sometimes I don’t know what my personal feelings are on this song regarding if I’m a big fan or not, because since they’ve debuted last summer around the same time, I’m more of the Blaze On guy; funny, I always think of those two songs together because of Summer Tour 2015. I usually think of the song as a great song to blast off into a more serious jam, but just a pretty straightforward funk song on its own. At this show, the song revealed itself to me as not just a place to jump into the stratosphere from, but a good song on its own to get the crowd going out of the gate. Cheers to that, and an even bigger cheers to what came next…

DOWN WITH DISEASE – Honestly, now that we are in the 3.0 era, when are we not excited to get a DWD in the early part of Set II??? I could listen to that DWD guitar lick we all love and know so well ALL DAY EVERY DAY and it will always succeed in getting me pumped for what is to come out of it. For me, that guitar lick is one of the trademark musical sections of this band. Kudos to the two guys behind me who were singing “NMINML” with me when we both had fun realizing we both heard the same tease at the same time. DWD is always a good time, but what hit next was probably what I will remember most from this show on a very personal note…

CITIES – MY FIRST CITIES. I could try to express my love of Phish’s take on this Talking Heads song and the way it gives me the down-and-dirty-southern-Charleston-covered-in-grits-feel that I love oh so much, but I don’t have to because we all feel the same way collectively. At the 8-minute mark of DWD, the band slows things down and gets sludgy for all 13,000 of us in the coliseum and this awesome dirty jam led into the tasty-like-gravy segue (and I mean legit segue, none of that “song stops and Fishman plays on his hi-hat a little bit while we go into the start of the next song” crap). This Cities is slow baby, and it fits perfectly with Charleston and what we were all wanting down in the south for this Fall Tour. Raymond from Augusta hugged me and thanked me for this because I spoke to him earlier about how much I would love a Cities since I have yet to catch one. I hope y’all all enjoy Gordo and Trey’s Bass/Marimba Lumina battle as much as I did! Think of Charleston, small city… well, on this night, the coliseum felt like we were our own city and Philadelphia had nothing on our brotherly love. And I love Elvis, so thank you Elvis for bringing your spirit down for this one!

ROGGAE – I’ve always enjoyed this song. In my head, I tend to pair this song together with Limb By Limb because they are both chill and not super heavy or loud fast, but perfectly fitting to follow up after that great molasses that came before. Always a pleaser for me if it is placed in an appropriate spot, and it was at this show.

TWENTY YEARS LATER – I view this as the curveball they pitched tonight, and I liked it. The song is cool, no monster or anything, but I think we can all love the fact that Twenty Years Later is our breather of the set, am I right?! “Hey man, it could’ve been The Line, so I’ll take it!” ;D

LIGHT – Light was GREAT tonight. I feel the song has two sides to it: it can either meander with its usual Lighty-self and the next thing we know we are in the next song and we look back and see it was just filler. Then we have the Lights we love so much that blast us off into outer space and land us on the moon; we dance around as hard as we can until that one guy grabs the American flag that was placed there so many years ago, you know, that one we weren’t supposed to touch?! He waves it around and runs around like a mad man and we then find ourselves just cheering him on because he had the balls to do it. That was last night’s Light. Have fun with the NMINML tease that begin at the 7:30 min mark. The jam they play with at 10:40 in is the jam we heard somewhere earlier this summer. I can’t remember which it is, but my gut is saying maybe the Ghost LOCKN? I could very easily be wrong, but it is from one of the jams I loved most in Summer 2016.

FREE – Who is dumb enough to ever say that they didn’t want to hear Free? I had my arms wide open and up in the air and I was taking in every minute of it, making sure I didn’t miss my chances to yell “FREEEEEEE”. I always enjoy the breakdown, always enjoy Gordo slapping my ass, oops I mean his bass.

BOOGIE ON REGGAE WOMAN – YES YES YES PLEASE OH YES DO NOT STOP. GIVE IT TO ME HARDER. ( I enjoyed myself)

HARRY HOOD – For the sake of time since we want to get going to an aquarium around the area before tonight’s sequel, let me just say that I always feel good about Hood and this set just reminded me of that important part of life.

SET TWO SUMMARY – One for the books people. This book will be place on my shelf at a spot that is easily accessible for me to grab whenever needed. Y’all down here will never see no dust on this book!
PLEASE, READ THE BOOK!!!!

PS – For the encore talk, we stayed part wat into Winterqueen but I didn’t feel the need to stay and believed I had my fill and was ready for heading out the doors. I got back to our place and saw that they had played Tube and Rocky Top after WQ, and thought “Man, I would’ve stayed if the encore was Tube>Rocky Top!” I love those tunes, but honestly, it’s all good everybody, I got all the amazing memories I could handle on the first night of Fall Tour in Chucktown. Also, we went to Wafflehouse after the show and I had a blast there eating an amazing hashbrown bowlwith scrambled eggs and sausage. Ronya at Waffle House was wonderful and she gave me my hash browns the way she likes them, so I was calling it the Ronya Special Hashbrown Bowl. People work so hard at that joint man, I love sitting at the bar and watching them put the food together. After seeing a great Phish show and appreciating people and life, the Wafflehouse was a wonderful experience that transcended what a normal Wafflehouse experience is to an everyday visitor.

The P-Fish – changing Waffle Houses everywhere, one tour stop at a time.

- Timbo
, attached to 2016-10-14

Review by Meatballs

Meatballs Last night was like a replay of my favorite nightmare. I haven’t returned until now to see my tormentor who assures me I’ll live unhappily ever after. He builds me up just to break what’s left of my brittle faith. He knows my desires and lures me in with temptations of euphoric shredding and crunchy jams. I’m left always convinced that the hurt will be worth it because his whale call wizardry will heal me. When I’m in his realm there’s no spectrum to recognize; there are only two states of being. The first is ephemeral, simply a prerequisite feeling of bliss like sipping the effervescent waters of the Gamehendge River. It’s a joyous triumph rich with erections that make your bones scream. This celestial state of divine peace implies you're safe but in actuality you’ve let your guard down and your frame gets blown out of the sky like Pan Am Flight 103. While you’re flying high, he’s unbuckled your seat belt, laughing as you pitch downward into a fiery death spiral. What started as the perfect honeymoon is now a game of exploding kittens in the Syrian Desert. This is exactly why I came back.
Add a Review
Setlist Filter
By year:

By month:

By day:

By weekday:

By artist:

Filter Reset Filters
Support Phish.net & MBIRD
Fun with Setlists

Trey Anastasio Band: November 18, 2005
12 years ago
Palace Theatre

Set 1: Air Said to Me, Plasma, Low, Cayman Review, Simple Twist Up Dave, Shine, Drifting, Sleep Again, Sweet Dreams Melinda, Invisible[1], Tuesday[2], The Inlaw Josie Wales[3], Wolfman's Brother[3] > Prince Caspian[3], Limb By Limb[3], Loving Cup[3], Waste[3], Mr. Completely > Money, Love and Change, Ether Sunday

Encore: Gotta Jibboo

[1] Trey on acoustic with Jen and Christina on backing vocals.
[2] Acoustic, with Jen and Christina on backing vocals.
[3] Trey solo acoustic.

Check our Phish setlists and sideshow setlists!


Phish.net

Phish.net is a non-commercial project run by Phish fans and for Phish fans under the auspices of the all-volunteer, non-profit Mockingbird Foundation.

This project serves to compile, preserve, and protect encyclopedic information about Phish and their music.

Credits | Terms Of Use | Legal

© 1990-2017  The Mockingbird Foundation, Inc. | Hosted by End Point Corporation