Thursday 08/21/2025 by Lemuria

10 YEARS SINCE MAGNABALL

[This post was written by ChatGPT - "written in the style of The Prairie Home Companion - because I wasn't actually at Magnaball but wanted to make sure that we honored the diennial anniversary and no one has stepped up yet. It does not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of any of the many volunteers who help with site content or help manage Phish.net, but it's far from terrible - and I invite you to comment with your own memories and reminiscences, and to contact me if you'd like to write about any upcoming anniversaries.]

Ten years ago today, out in the quiet fields of Watkins Glen, there was a gathering, and like most gatherings worth remembering, it began with long drives, coolers of sandwiches, and the low murmur of anticipation in the August heat. Folks set up their tents in sprawling neighborhoods of nylon and shade tarps, as though an entire town had risen up overnight. And in a way, it had—complete with makeshift cafés, impromptu parades of glowsticks, and an unspoken promise that, for three days, time would slow down and life would feel different, a little lighter, and a lot more musical.

The band, of course, played their part with patience and generosity. Sets unfurled like late-summer afternoons: deliberate, sometimes languid, sometimes quickening with a sudden joy, the way a breeze will lift the curtains just so. There were jams that wandered far beyond the expected borders and came back home again with a kind of triumphant humility, as if to say, “See, we knew where we were going all along.” For those who were there, it was music not just heard but absorbed, sewn into the very fabric of the weekend.

And then there were the in-between hours—the afternoons of swimming and lounging, the evenings of communal cooking, the late nights when art installations hummed quietly in the dark. You could walk through the campgrounds and hear the echo of laughter travel like fireflies between tents, or stumble into conversations with strangers who seemed, for the moment, like lifelong friends. The festival wasn’t just a sequence of shows; it was a portrait of what it feels like when thousands of people agree to leave ordinary life behind, just for a little while.

Now, a decade later, Magnaball feels both distant and immediate, like a dream you wake from but can recall in perfect detail. We tell the stories again and again—of the drive-in set that felt like a secret gift, of the jams that stretched impossibly wide, of the feeling of belonging in that great wide pasture. And as with all good stories, they grow softer and sweeter with age, not because the facts change, but because our hearts do. Magnaball was a weekend when the music was good, the people were kind, and the world, at least for a time, seemed a little more generous than usual.

[Supplemental links provided by Lemuria, not ChatGPT. Relying entirely on AI would be uberlame, amirite?]

Setlists: Friday, Saturday, Sunday

Jesse Jarnow's review in Rolling Stone

Forum thread about Jarnow's review

Forum thread about the best set at Magnaball

JohhnyD's reflections one year out

If you liked this blog post, one way you could "like" it is to make a donation to The Mockingbird Foundation, the sponsor of Phish.net. Support music education for children, and you just might change the world.


Comments

, comment by Phishead23
Phishead23 Phish needs to get back on tour. A complainer complaining about people complaining and an Ai written post. 😂 When did I get transported to the horrible simulation.
, comment by mcgrupp81
mcgrupp81 The AI’s disdain for Prince Caspian, resulting in its performance at Magnball being excluded from this recap, is EXACTLY what KevinForbin was talking about in the last article. Vindication for Kevin.
, comment by dirtydave420
dirtydave420 Superball 9 was much better. The rented 'security' at Watkins Glenn was atrocious.
, comment by GhostDawg
GhostDawg What is going on with the "blog"
, comment by PauperCaspian
PauperCaspian Yes that’s exactly what happened. ;)
, comment by dirtydave420
dirtydave420 Now that we are replacing post with AI garbage, let's replace the band too... who needs the boys when AI can do it for us....
, comment by thefreewheelin76
thefreewheelin76 Auto ignore. AI slop is the opposite of what the scene is about. I'll never slight the folks who post recaps or blogs. When there's a lull, that is OK. Don't fill the silence with shit. Let it breathe, then have real posts come when it's right.
, comment by theincrediblepurp
theincrediblepurp If you are gonna post articles written by AI, just don’t post anything that day instead.
, comment by percussionrinse
percussionrinse Using ChatGPT is not only environmentally disastrous, but seems like the total antithesis to Phish and what they stand for.
, comment by Phineform
Phineform I see all these complaints about AI, but as long as it keeps delivering poetry that far exceeds what any human can write, I’m there for it. I mean really think about this statement from the article, comparing the music of the festival to …. “the way a breeze will lift the curtains just so”. I mean common, that brought a tear to my eye. It’s exactly how I felt but my brain could have never reached that perfect ANALogy
, comment by FrontMan
FrontMan Hot take I guess but I thought this post was pretty cool. An experimental prompt from which real conversation could occur. Looking at it for what it is - and not what it isn’t - I thought it did a pretty damn good job summing up Magnaball in the limited space it had. Without hitting on specifics, i think it did actually reference the almighty Tweezer>Caspian jam, but whatever. It sure was a magical time and space 10 years ago at WG! Tentpole of my 37 year Phish journey. To this day, the last 5-6 minutes of Caspian jam offers the most inspired, risk-reward musical moments I’ve witnessed live. A wave of utter awe permeated the collective. A pinnacle many of us will forever hold sacred. Put that in the context of the fest leading up to it and after and it’s just exactly perfect. I love that our band is still creating new tent poles (see 7.27.25) 10 years later and would love to read other’s memories of Magnaball as it helps keep mine alive.
, comment by jahroy
jahroy This is sad.
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Support Phish.net & Mbird
Fun with Setlists
Check our Phish setlists and sideshow setlists!
Phish News
Subscribe to Phish-News for exclusive info while on tour!


Phish.net

Phish.net is a non-commercial project run by Phish fans and for Phish fans under the auspices of the all-volunteer, non-profit Mockingbird Foundation.

This project serves to compile, preserve, and protect encyclopedic information about Phish and their music.

Credits | Terms Of Use | Legal | DMCA

© 1990-2025  The Mockingbird Foundation, Inc.