Thursday 01/01/2015 by bertoletdown


For me, 2014 was full of death and fracture and noise; a year to be ceremoniously booted in the ass and sent packing. It was brightened and softened in its waning days by the news of not one, not two, but three wedding engagements, and by the arrival of a few beautiful bouncing babies. But like many in my family and circle of friends, I couldn’t be happier about turning this page.

Photo by Scott Harris

These inverted holiday runs don’t lend themselves to that kind of punctuation. Expectations peak before the music has a chance to simmer and build flavor. You could argue that the band does itself a disservice by starting a run on New Year’s Eve (or Halloween, for that matter), and a few people I know who wouldn’t dream of missing NYE at MSG took a pass on Miami for just that reason, so it’s a safe bet that the crowd assembled for these shows in Miami is a die-hard and devoted bunch.

The band spends most of the first set validating the couch tour contingent’s decision to skip the trip, and dipping their toes into the pool. There are scattered moments worthy of note, like Page’s stinging Hammond leads in “555” and some spirited chicken picking from Trey in “Heavy Things.” The culminating “ASIHTOS” manages to transcend the cautious and contained quality of what happened before it, and promise bigger things in set two.

Photo by Scott Harris

Despite stumbling out of the gates with a rather clumsy and truncated take on “Birds of a Feather,” the band delivers on that promise with an electrifying second frame. “Ghost” demonstrates major potential in its composed section, with the entire band feeling loose and comfortable for what feels like the first time all night. After a few minutes of improv, the harmonic mood brightens and we’re treated to a homeward stroll through sunkissed pastures. The approach for the first half of this jam is classic “WentGin’”: a patient meditation on primary colors. The band then retreats to the minor, seemingly ready to end the song, but Trey has bigger plans and decides to break off some climactic blues riffs before succumbing to the allure of deep space.

Theme From The Bottom” surfaces from the ooze. It is hard to quarrel with second set “Themes,” especially when they are given their proper due. During the “from the bottom / from the top” vocal coda, Trey has another “we’re not done yet” moment and begins scratching on his strings. Fish picks up on this immediately and proposes a second jam that quickly veers into thrilling and chilling territory. Trey takes a back seat to both Mike and Page here, content to let them steer a bit, and Page drops a few “They Attack!” samples before we slide deftly into the most creative and inspired “Cities” since Berkeley 2010.

If you take your Phish loose and playful like party conversation, this is your jam. The band eschews showboating and huddles together in one of those “only Phish” moments of musical brotherhood to assemble something truly beautiful. “Cities” is unduly interrupted, alas, by a “Chalk Dust Torture” that fails to earn its second set stripes, but which hardly diminishes the distilled triumph of the “Theme” -> “Cities” sequence.

Martian Monster,” complete with album samples, lays to rest any doubt that this year’s Halloween material will find a berth in the repertoire. Page does some terrific headfucking on his Nord here before migrating to his clav and driving the band to a frenzied peak… and that’s all she wrote for set two.

Photo by @thebigmic33

The gag that opens the midnight set will go down as one of the band’s least memorable ones, if I had to guess. The best part of it may well be the Phish debut of “Dem Bones,” which immediately takes its place as the most satisfying a capella tune the band does these days. “Auld Lang Syne” spills into “The Dogs,” which is over before it begins, but which surrenders to an action-packed “Tweezer” that expends everything that’s left in the band’s reserve tank. This classic song saw something of a retreat in 2014 after a legendary showing in 2013, so it is gratifying to see the year end with a heroic version of this caliber.

Unfortunately, there’s little to recommend of what remains in this final set, all of which feels devoid of purpose and just a bit flat (save for a few measures of raw power in “Bug”).

But hey: it’s the first of four nights, and the highlights tonight were hardly anything to sneeze at. The “Theme” -> “Cities” combo stands up to anything Phish has played in 2014, and that’s something I never imagined I’d be saying. Keep your knees loose, folks, and have a wonderful 2015!

If you liked this blog post, one way you could "like" it is to make a donation to The Mockingbird Foundation, the sponsor of Support music education for children, and you just might change the world.


FACTSAREUSELESS Thanks for the review. Nice balanced commentary. I love Theme and this was certainly a keeper and perhaps the best one since Philly '03, though still not in the same class. Tweezer is my favorite number by the boys among the jam staples and I agree with your commentary about both the song and this version.

Any gag that lampoons Fishman is AOKAY in my book. Certainly not as epic as '09 though. But after Halloween they certainly get a pass in the creativity front.

Thanks again Chris.
, comment by shaunfunk
shaunfunk Fun show last night ! Yes the theme > cities was a highlight to be celebrated and the gag left a little to be desired after phish has set the bar so high. Hey reviewer, you lost me at "For me,...." And it's 2015 now so get used to writing it !! Hahaha.
, comment by NeverEndingSplend0r
NeverEndingSplend0r Have to chime in and say, this is one of the best concert reviews I've ever read. I'm of the camp that firmly believes "writing about music is like dancing about architecture". I used to write about music myself until I realized I was better at dancing (not a good dancer, BTW),I should perhaps consider a career in architecture.

Your knowledge of the band, and the nuts and bolts of music, combined with elegant prose, lack of hyperbole, and not making the article about you, make this a really pleasant read.

Congrats. I hope you do more of what you do cause you do it well.

Carry on,and happy new year!
Carry on.
, comment by dpwilljr
dpwilljr Just an outstanding second set. I could take the time and effort to break it down and criticize each song.....
With sets like this, it's better to look at it as one piece of music. Kind of like Philip Glass "Einstein On The Beach".
, comment by GAphishin
GAphishin Second set blew my mind. I would agree that the boys were looking to find purchase in the first set. But holy moly that second set was joyous and beautiful! Lots of exploration and coming out of an estranged birds of a feather to open, I was honored to be behind the stage and watch that place take off with common celebration.
, comment by bertoletdown
bertoletdown @biskithweels: Thanks for your very kind comment. I really appreciate it, and I hope you also have a marvelous new year!
, comment by JahNuhDead
JahNuhDead That Heavy Things was the best I've ever heard. Particularly Trey.
, comment by dumidiot
dumidiot I'm gonna come out and say it: this show topped 1/3. The jamming was way more pleasing to my ear, and when you stack that tweezer on too of the second set, I'm just boggled that this show is getting trashed. Even the first set had some REALLY strong playing that tops out 1/3 set 1. Id go so far as to call it criminally underrated.
, comment by bertoletdown
bertoletdown @dumidiot said:
I'm gonna come out and say it: this show topped 1/3. The jamming was way more pleasing to my ear, and when you stack that tweezer on too of the second set, I'm just boggled that this show is getting trashed. Even the first set had some REALLY strong playing that tops out 1/3 set 1. Id go so far as to call it criminally underrated.
What did you think was special about the first set?

It was distinctly first setty to these ears. YMMV of course.
You must be logged in to post a comment. is a non-commercial project run by Phish fans and for Phish fans under the auspices of the all-volunteer, non-profit Mockingbird Foundation.

This project serves to compile, preserve, and protect encyclopedic information about Phish and their music.

Credits | Terms Of Use | Legal | DMCA

© 1990-2023  The Mockingbird Foundation, Inc. | Hosted by Linode