Mystery Jam Monday Part 170

Monday 12/16/2013 by bl002e

MYSTERY JAM MONDAY PART 170

With only twelve days to go until the MSG run begins, take your shot at the 170th installment of Phish.net's Mystery Jam Monday. As usual, this week's winner will receive an MP3 download courtesy of our friends at LivePhish.com / Nugs.Net. To win, be the first person to identify the song and date of the mystery jam clip. Each person gets one guess per day, with the second “day” starting after I post the hint. A hint will be posted on Tuesday if necessary, with the answer to follow on Wednesday. Good luck!

Hint: As of Tuesday at 10:00am, not one of the 22 comments has guessed either the correct song or show that this jam is from.

Answer: We have yet another first-time winner, as @12zlavin recognized the 7/12/13 David Bowie -- well done!

MJM #171 will return in January. I just want to express my appreciation for those of you who participate in Mystery Jam Monday. I'm constantly in awe of your knowledge of Phish's music, and the challenge in stumping you makes this as fun for me on this side of the game as it was on the other side. Have a great holiday week, enjoy nine more sets of 2013 Phish, and hope to see you at the official MBF Phish.Net Meetup on 12/29.

72 comments - Link: http://phi.sh/b/52af4ace

Comments

2013-12-16 2:09 pm, comment by pflaumja

Reba 10-31-94

Score: 0

2013-12-16 2:33 pm, comment by WayIFeel

6.16.12 Light

Score: 0

2013-12-16 3:55 pm, comment by fas0latid0

Sounds very similar to 6/16 Light but thats not it. Sounds like maybe 1999-2000, maybe a Simple jam?

Score: 0

2013-12-16 4:18 pm, comment by Babyrattlesnakes

I'll toss out 9/1/12 Light as my random guess

Score: 0

2013-12-16 4:44 pm, comment by Bob_Loblaw

12/2/09 light

Score: 0

2013-12-16 5:25 pm, comment by Irish41123

10/19/10 Light

Score: 0

2013-12-16 5:26 pm, comment by drucifer

7-5-13 light

Score: 0

2013-12-16 5:27 pm, comment by stevemott

8/31/13 Chalkdust

Score: 0

2013-12-16 5:29 pm, comment by markhood

Sneakin Sally 06-04-2011

Score: 0

2013-12-16 6:04 pm, comment by bostonron

Whatever it is I like it

Score: 5

2013-12-16 8:01 pm, comment by L1verK1ck

10/19/10 Reba

Score: 0

2013-12-16 9:10 pm, comment by jdub77

7/3/11 Light

Score: 0

2013-12-16 10:09 pm, comment by Brandonclick77

I hear Stash

Score: 1

2013-12-16 11:02 pm, comment by davenschaeffer

9/3/11 Tweezer

Score: 0

2013-12-17 12:26 am, comment by bostonron

7/2/97 Stash

Score: 0

2013-12-17 1:54 am, comment by MOMAreprise

12/31/2003 stash

Score: 0

2013-12-17 5:23 am, comment by Ez_and_not_so_Fast

Boy, Man! This one really sticks a crab in my shoemouth.

I can't quite place it even now, in the age of miracles and in this age of sound...

Score: 2

2013-12-17 8:03 am, comment by Squirrel

I was thinking Golden Age too.

Score: 1

2013-12-17 8:59 am, comment by beerphish

7/3/2013 Golden Age

Score: 0

2013-12-17 9:42 am, comment by mgrant0213

7/3/12 Golden Age

Score: 0

2013-12-17 9:51 am, comment by forbin1

10/20/13 Golden Age

Score: 0

2013-12-17 9:52 am, comment by MiguelSanchez

sounds 3.0.... other than that, this dude's stumped.

Score: 2

2013-12-17 10:41 am, comment by drshaws

Crap. I was going with the 8/31/13 Chalkdust.

Instead, I venture forth - Carini - SPAC - 7/6/13

Score: 0

2013-12-17 10:52 am, comment by Ouish

Gonna take a wild guess cause I don't have time to search...

Simple 08/06/2010 Greek

Score: 0

2013-12-17 11:00 am, comment by mcgrupp81

@mgrant0213 said:

7/3/12 Golden Age

I listened to this one yesterday and I don't think it's that one. This is a nice jam.

Score: 0

2013-12-17 11:08 am, comment by GottaJibboo

Sounds 3.0. Sounds like its completely outdoors (i.e. no pavilion to hold the sound down). Thought it was a Carini, but can't seem to find it.

Good luck!

Score: 0

2013-12-17 11:24 am, comment by forbin1

3.0 for sure

Score: 1

2013-12-17 11:35 am, comment by wccox3

Seven Below 11/28/09

Score: 0

2013-12-17 11:51 am, comment by Phish686

9/1/13 David Bowie

Score: 0

2013-12-17 12:15 pm, comment by Doctor_Smarty

7/30/13 Ghost

Score: 0

2013-12-17 12:18 pm, comment by drshaws

@GottaJibboo said:

Sounds 3.0. Sounds like its completely outdoors (i.e. no pavilion to hold the sound down).

My thoughts exactly. You can hear some fan talk about her Mom at the end of the clip. Why isn't that in any official reviews?

Score: 0

2013-12-17 12:26 pm, comment by Choda

Not sold that it's 3.0...there is something more to that hint

Score: 2

2013-12-17 12:28 pm, comment by woodballs

Gumbo 98 Gorge

Score: 0

2013-12-17 12:42 pm, comment by Choda

10/22/10 Rock and Roll

Score: 0

2013-12-17 12:54 pm, comment by Lee_Fordham

10/22/96 Down with Disease

Score: 0

2013-12-17 1:22 pm, comment by Maggiesfarm2001

Steam 7/5/13

Score: 0

2013-12-17 1:28 pm, comment by uctweezer

@Choda said:

Not sold that it's 3.0...there is something more to that hint

When was the hint posted? It could be that one of the comments after 10 AM contains one or the other...

Score: 0

2013-12-17 1:40 pm, comment by NickSalv

wow, davenschaeffer was super close with the 9/3/11 Tweezer, but it doesnt quite sound exact...

Score: 0

2013-12-17 1:53 pm, comment by Choda

@uctweezer said:

@Choda said:
Not sold that it's 3.0...there is something more to that hint
When was the hint posted? It could be that one of the comments after 10 AM contains one or the other...

Only one comment and that was the SPAC Carini guess

Score: 0

2013-12-17 2:00 pm, comment by andrewrose

@Choda said:

@uctweezer said:
@Choda said:
Not sold that it's 3.0...there is something more to that hint
When was the hint posted? It could be that one of the comments after 10 AM contains one or the other...
Only one comment and that was the SPAC Carini guess

I don't think it's 3.0 either.

Score: 0

2013-12-17 2:03 pm, comment by uctweezer

Carini 10/31/13

Score: 0

2013-12-17 2:04 pm, comment by WayIFeel

10.30.98 Tweezer

Score: 0

2013-12-17 2:31 pm, comment by Harold_of_the_Coast

7/31/13 Carini

Score: 0

2013-12-17 2:45 pm, comment by Pregnant_hens

10.30.98 manteca

Score: 1

2013-12-17 3:07 pm, comment by GottaJibboo

@andrewrose said:

@Choda said:
@uctweezer said:
@Choda said:
Not sold that it's 3.0...there is something more to that hint
When was the hint posted? It could be that one of the comments after 10 AM contains one or the other...
Only one comment and that was the SPAC Carini guess
I don't think it's 3.0 either.

I disagree and think it is 3.0. The girl talking gives away this is an aud recording. And I'm not sure the technology was around in 1.0 or 2.0 to obtain such a crisp sound. If I'm wrong, this may be the clearest pre-3.0 aud recording I've ever heard.

That said, it's probably not 3.0 to further confuse us. @bl002e loves to do that!

Score: 0

2013-12-17 3:12 pm, comment by stevemott

12/31/10 YEM

Score: 0

2013-12-17 3:25 pm, comment by Man_From_Mars

8/3/1998 Gumbo

Score: 0

2013-12-17 3:46 pm, comment by Choda

@GottaJibboo said: "@andrewrose said: "@Choda said: "@uctweezer said: "@Choda said: "Not sold that it's 3.0...there is something more to that hint"

When was the hint posted? It could be that one of the comments after 10 AM contains one or the other..."

Only one comment and that was the SPAC Carini guess"

I don't think it's 3.0 either."

I disagree and think it is 3.0. The girl talking gives away this is an aud recording. And I'm not sure the technology was around in 1.0 or 2.0 to obtain such a crisp sound. If I'm wrong, this may be the clearest pre-3.0 aud recording I've ever heard.

That said, it's probably not 3.0 to further confuse us. @bl002e loves to do that!"

Really? I think it sounds awful. Mike is flat and fish man sounds like he is in a tunnel. There are many great 1.0 auds.

Score: 1

2013-12-17 4:41 pm, comment by Babyrattlesnakes

5/28/11 Bathtub Gin

Score: 0

2013-12-17 5:16 pm, comment by MJZ1974

McGrupp - 6-28-12 Deer Creek

Score: 0

2013-12-17 5:23 pm, comment by The__Van

Ah, the infamous "you haven't guessed it" hint.

Score: 2

2013-12-17 5:24 pm, comment by Hosemaster93

7/12/2013 David Bowie

Score: 11

2013-12-17 5:44 pm, comment by bostonron

Will someone just guess this correctly already. I want to hear the jam in its entirety.

Score: 0

2013-12-17 5:46 pm, comment by dlb12

Backwards Down the Number Line 12/30/12

Score: 0

2013-12-17 5:52 pm, comment by Hosemaster93

I'm fairly certain that my guess was right, http://www.phishtracks.com/shows/2013-07-12/david-bowie , start listening at like 7:18ish, 7:15 to be safe.

Score: 11

2013-12-17 6:05 pm, comment by hukle88

^^^^Winner^^^^

Score: 1

2013-12-17 6:17 pm, comment by GottaJibboo

The MJM recording sounds much better than the PhishTracks version. Good work @Hosemaster93. I knew it was 3.0 and a completely outdoor show though...

Score: 3

2013-12-17 7:25 pm, comment by mcgrupp81

Nice get. I haven't had to time to poke around but there's no way I would have gotten it and I went to the freaking show and have the SBDs. The Tweezer/Cities/Rock and Roll from that show are much more heralded but the Reba and Bowie from that first set were nice too. I was shivering by the time that Bowie came on. Rain=Pain. Saw a guy at set break wearing a wet suit. Guess I can't complain with the Toronto mayhem and the many soaked shows of Summer 2013.

Score: 1

2013-12-17 10:37 pm, comment by NickSalv

nice job @Hosemaster93 !

checked this show, and I think I was paying too close attention to the Tweeze and those segues, definitely threw me off.

anyway, there's a fantastic Reba> Bowie at that show... honestly we need to see more of this pairing, and to end a first set even! look back to SBIX for another example, one of the top Rebas from that year and the Bowie was no slouch either

Score: 3

2013-12-18 12:06 am, comment by officercookies

very non bowie sounding.
I agree

Score: 2

2013-12-18 5:56 am, comment by TheLeprechaun

Reba '94. All I got.

Score: 0

2013-12-18 6:08 am, comment by melt_the_tek9

Jon's drumbeat sounds fall 97 to me, the closeness of the girl talking had me listening to Europe shows from early 97 since monday! lol, thanks for getting this, this Bowie jam is so sweeeeeeeeeet

Score: 2

2013-12-18 8:35 am, comment by MiguelSanchez

@Hosemaster93 said:

I'm fairly certain that my guess was right, http://www.phishtracks.com/shows/2013-07-12/david-bowie , start listening at like 7:18ish, 7:15 to be safe.

nice work. i haven't spent more time listening to the second set. i gave the first set one listen through. I remember liking the bowie, but clearly, i need to give it another listen!!

Score: 1

2013-12-18 11:17 am, comment by mcgrupp81

@NickSalv said:

nice job @Hosemaster93 !

checked this show, and I think I was paying too close attention to the Tweeze and those segues, definitely threw me off.

anyway, there's a fantastic Reba> Bowie at that show... honestly we need to see more of this pairing, and to end a first set even! look back to SBIX for another example, one of the top Rebas from that year and the Bowie was no slouch either

Hell yeah. The Reba, Axilla II, Bowie to end set I of 7/3/94 is dynamite.

Score: 0

2013-12-18 12:41 pm, comment by somecoldgreentea

I couldn't not hear Foam everytime I played it.

Score: 0

2013-12-18 6:44 pm, comment by Hosemaster93

So I've never won this before, how does the whole mp3 download prize work? haha

Score: 0

2013-12-18 8:41 pm, comment by Anteloperunner

Frankenstein 8/9/98

Score: 0

2013-12-18 8:44 pm, comment by Anteloperunner

The author has removed all of the text from their comment

Score: 0

2013-12-19 5:05 pm, comment by aparisi

7/12/13 - david bowie

Score: 0

2013-12-19 6:29 pm, comment by Autoo

fee

Score: 0

2013-12-19 9:15 pm, comment by Ravinus

fluff

Score: 0

2013-12-19 10:05 pm, comment by UbiquitousSmokey

well, even though i never stated a guess im taking this as a boost to my morale - i knew it had to be a bowie, and from jon's drumming had to be 2013.

closest ive ever been to getting a right answer in this game.

Score: 0