Wednesday 06/08/2011 by pzerbo


On Tuesday night Phish rolled into Great Woods, home of many a classic Phish gig, for their only performance this year in New England proper. On the heels of a smoking hot weekend (Pine Knob and Blossom in particular), the comparatively modest performances at this shed from the past two summers (6/6/09 and 6/22/10), and the brilliant summer sun, anticipation was high and the crowd was pumped.

The workmanlike first set was light on improvisational exploration but not without highlights. A rocking, high-energy “Llama” opened the proceedings, and the energy stayed high through an enjoyable if interchangeable series of “Moma Dance” > “Possum” and “Cities.” While “Moma” is perfunctory by nature, hopes for a pattern of jamming emerging on the heels of the brilliant “Possum” from Blossom and the well-above average “Cities” from Bethel were, unfortunately, dashed. Nevertheless a fun sequence. The return of “Instant Karma!” for only the second Phish performance (6/12/10) added some unexpected spice to the set; way to go, Page! “David Bowie” followed in an unusual mid-first set slot. Kudos for the placement, but this version was apparently ordered “no extra mustard” as it never really got off the ground.

The Phish debut of Al Green’s “Rhymes” – a standard in the Mike Gordon Band repertoire – was a welcome addition and hopefully a harbinger of more songs from the rotation of Mike’s “other band” seeping into Phish setlists. The real meat of this set was indisputably “The Divided Sky” that was both precisely rendered and soaring in intensity, laying a punishing smack down to the jaded vet loser who used the occasion to cycle liquids. But to be fair I only missed half of the song. :-) “Stealing Time” finished off the first set proceedings, taking a sharp step back from the highs of “Divided,” but rocked, compactly, as it is obliged to do. Overall, the jamming jets were mostly in the closed position but it was a perfectly enjoyable set with a mini-rarity, a debut, and a spectacular “Divided.” We’ll be back in fifteen minutes.

Back on the Train” opened set two and was relaxed, lilting and a bit funky but (you knew it was coming at least once) Trey cut the jam a little short, opting for “Rock and Roll.” In this case, nice choice! Wow, just wow! For a 16+ minute version it wasn’t “exploratory” but it was absolutely dense-packed with power and energy. This was far and away the highlight of the night; do yourself a favor and download this show if only for this “R&R,” you don’t want to miss it. Great stuff! “Mango Song” follows and was a fantastic choice to bring down the energy level without crushing it entirely. Then “Bug,” that personally I love but the placement was questionable and there was a palpable deflation of crowd energy. Oh well, it doesn’t matter!

Pebbles and Marbles” didn’t do much for the energy flow of the show, but is such a great song that Trey can be forgiven for mild misjudgement in the setlist arrangement, and the performance was excellent in any case. After the fantastic version in Bethel, “Halley’s” reverted into the 3.0 shell in which jams hide. “Meatstick” was fun, as always, though several commenters have noted that this song works better when deployed less often and I tend to agree, but at least a few of us still actually do the dance. “Antelope” was great, and in a “OK kids, let’s review what we’ve done today” approach included “Meatstick,” “Bug” and “Divided Sky” teases. The “Suzy” encore was stock rock fun, and that is a wrap.

Overall? Sorry, co-workers, but you can’t make me use the numeric scale! My mind doesn’t work that way with Phish. I’m there for the fun, the friends, and of course great music in the moment, and there was all of that and more, a fantastic night of entertainment in my home venue. The venue was fantastic, as always, no issues anywhere, excepting the shit-show traffic on the exit, but we weren’t in a big hurry so no worries. My “categories” such as they are: There are maybe ~5% of shows that are outliers on the low end, 10% of shows that are outliers on the high end, and the remainder are “average,” i.e. rock solid entertainment. In that light this was an average Phish show. It was not a home run and excepting the “Rock and Roll” the jamming jets were on cool, but worth every penny and more. Good times!

On a final note, I will use a numeric scale to describe Squidda, the lower Cape’s premier jam outfit that played in the RV/Bus lot before and after Phish: 10! Out of 10! (OK they are friends so please forgive me one innocent plug).

If you liked this blog post, one way you could "like" it is to make a donation to The Mockingbird Foundation, the sponsor of Support music education for children, and you just might change the world.


, comment by ADAWGWYO
ADAWGWYO You mean Possum from Blossom, but I get ya.
, comment by pzerbo
pzerbo Thanks Andrew, edited. D'oh!
, comment by joechip
joechip Nice review. Nailed the assessment, I like your style of review. Thanks. Questionable choices in the "energy flow" department held the show back a little. Pebbles and Marbles was very welcome and I hope more of the "2.0" songs continue to work their way back into sets.
, comment by ColForbin
ColForbin Nice review, @pzerbo. Divided was nicely executed, for sure. The Rock and Roll jam is definitely something I'll be revisiting, and the recent trend of throwing in lots of teases harkens back to some of my favorite show from the early 90s.

I have been known to use the 10 point rating scale in the past, this show seems like a quintessential example of a 5.0. Far better than the 09 show at Great Woods, which is more like a 2 or 3 in my book.

But lately I've been operating on a new scale with only three levels, kind of like yours: skip, AUD, SBD. The average fun show I'll grab an AUD, if it is really great I'll buy the SBD and the rare dud will be skipped. I make my decision after listening to the shows on the awesome LivePhish app. This GW show is firmly in the AUD camp. (no disrespect to tapers, the AUDs from this tour have been really excellent, it's more a question of whether the show is worth spending $ on)
, comment by RunawayJim
RunawayJim I don't mind the slower, more relaxed sets. People had a problem with Bethel's first night second set. I thought that was an awesome set. I loved the Waves-> Caspian. As such, I loved the Mango, Bug, Pebbles segment (could be because I've been chasing Mango and Pebbles). I really enjoyed the show. I didn't notice the aborted jam in BOTT, but the Halley's started to have a little jam at the end, similar to Bethel's, and was very obviously aborted when Trey decided it was time for the Meatstick.
, comment by djmeneses
djmeneses You guys at are doing a phenomenal job on the reviews. keep up the great work!
, comment by seanpatrick
seanpatrick does anyone beside me see the similarities between the GD'S lazy lightning, and the mansfield jam (after rock and roll on the sbd) from about 6:33 to about 7:10?? unless i'm just crazy, it'd be interesting consider massachusetts was hit with a ridiculous thunder and lightning show just last week...
You must be logged in to post a comment. is a non-commercial project run by Phish fans and for Phish fans under the auspices of the all-volunteer, non-profit Mockingbird Foundation.

This project serves to compile, preserve, and protect encyclopedic information about Phish and their music.

Credits | Terms Of Use | Legal | DMCA

© 1990-2021  The Mockingbird Foundation, Inc. | Hosted by Linode