This show is closer to four stars than three. While it doesn't have the set-craft and exploratory improvisation of a five star outing, one can find excellence in the beginning and end of the first set, and Mercury through Sand is a solidly constructed passage. I'm sure they will play multiple great versions of I always Wanted it That Way this tour; the debut was no exception. Not too many flubs or clams, which is important for delivering the experience I think they're trying to produce. Charleston is a fine city, and a Phish concert there is a bonus! I am not upset that I attended.