Ok. First of all, this show has every true phan's basic dream setlist. I mean, if this show were a greatest hits album, the setlist would live up to it.

Yes, this show has a few weak spots. In the first few minutes of this YEM, Trey just stops for a few seconds trying to find the right notes. In the intro to Sneakin' Sally, the sound is one-dimensional; there is something missing that would make it sound fuller. And Trey's voice sounds absolutely awful in Limb. But if you forget those individual moments and think about the show as a whole, it really is amazing. It has some amazing peaks in the Piper, as well as the Maze>Catapult>Maze sandwich. But what really crowns this show as an '04 gem is the epic space jam of Scents. It brings the show to an amazing close, and may be one of the finest Scents known to phistory. So I'd give a good 5 stars to this show, looking past the small mishaps.