Although this show obviously wasn't the tightest show they ever played, and trey isn't what he use to be, for a phish show this was easily a 5/5. One thing you have to remember about phish, at least for me and many others i know, it isn't just about the music( although it is the most important and best part).
Theres always a spectacle to phish, the people, the glowsticks, the atmosphere, the trey banter and anything else i forgot. With the balls and costumes and all kinds of crazy stuff at superball this was one of the greatest shows in a long time, never forget about the things that come along with phish, if you look at it from that point of view and if you were there you can understand why people think this was such a great show.