@muchado said:

no exile on main street, the acoustic set, or waiting for Columbus?

other than that thank you for read, you obviously put a lot of time into this and love the band dearly

Appreciate it! I talked about the Festival 8 acoustic set here: http://forum.phish.net/forum/permalink/1376571480 and here: http://forum.phish.net/forum/permalink/1376575601. As for the costume sets...I mean, I love the costume sets, but that's not really *Phish*, y'know? It's Phish playing someone else's music, and as much of their own spin as they put on said music, at the end of the day that's all that it is. 10/31/14 II is something entirely different.

@phunky58 said:

this is a great list but imho i don't agree with #1 at all, def think there should be more sets from fall 2013 and summer 2012, there only one set from each run. keep #8 , #7 , #6 , #5, and #2. then sprinkle in some more fall 2013 and summer 2012 and we got ourselves some straight fire.

Also appreciate the kind words - I'd figured the #1 choice would be a tad controversial. Summer '12 and Fall '13 are both well represented in the entire Top 50 + 11; I'm a bit surprised you can't find any straight fire in 7/31/15 II and 7/13/14 II, but hey.