@squail said:

I don't think it's overrated. Or at least, you can't make that claim from this data. We submitted 10 entries, but we didn't rank them. I put the Tahoe Tweezer on my list and I bet a lot of others did too because I wanted a ballot that included songs from every era. This Tweezer was my only 2009-2014 selection. I bet that's true for other voterss. So what you get is a worthy HOF song that likely had small competition from the era-standpoint, so it ends up on a high percentage of ballots, and is, imo, misinterpreted as being overrated. If the list had been ordinal, Tahow Tweezer would have been on the bottom of my list.

Well, there you have it.
You didn't rank the top Phish jams of all time, you put your own spin on it. Which is fine - but that is my point. It is not a top 10 (or 26, IMO) Phish jam of all time.
It's damn good, though. (Personally, I think the MSG Tweezer from 12/28/12 approaches its quality, and the Dick's Simple is a better jam.)