Permalink for Comment #1346781797 by pzerbo

, comment by pzerbo
pzerbo Folks, let's face it: the comments on show recaps have long-since jumped the shark. Write a positive, borderline fluffing recap; get slammed. Write a luke-warm recap; get slammed. Write a review from the couch; get slammed. Write about a personal experience from the show; get slammed. It starts with a particular someone who lurks in his parent's basement, just waiting, refresh, refresh... there it is! My moment! Slam the recap and the writer! Wow, that must be a an awesome moment in that person's otherwise dreadful, friend-less life. Good job. Now it's a trend. Awesome.

We know the criticism is coming. BFD. We keep it up, because among the 10K-20K views that a recap typically receives, there are at most a few dozen that feel the need to slam our efforts. The silent majority keeps coming back, so we'll keep at it. I think I can fairly speak for the group that maintains this site and offers recaps in one sense and in one sense only: we love Phish. We love Phish enough to take the time to offer what we hope is quality content. A few folks clearly don't like this content, but come back, day after day, to tell us how much we suck. To those who enjoy our content, we are thrilled to continue to offer our humble thoughts. To those who think we suck: GFY, brah, GFY. The irony, of course, is that people who want x, y, or z to be done differently offer no actual meaningful content of their own, but rather just slam the work of others.

For those who want "other people to recap" I'll cheerfully remind everyone that there are plenty of opportunities for user participation on this site. You have the forum to write, literally, whatever you want, within the bounds of our very liberal terms of service. All users are welcome to offer their own reviews in the show review section. All users are welcome to offer constructive thoughts in the blog comments; that so many of you chose to "go meta" and criticize others instead of talking about the music... well, we can't change that. Only you can change that.

Go ahead, now slam me, I can take it. /rant


Phish.net

Phish.net is a non-commercial project run by Phish fans and for Phish fans under the auspices of the all-volunteer, non-profit Mockingbird Foundation.

This project serves to compile, preserve, and protect encyclopedic information about Phish and their music.

Credits | Terms Of Use | Legal | DMCA

© 1990-2024  The Mockingbird Foundation, Inc. | Hosted by Linode