"Their originals sounded so familiar to me that I thought they MUST be covers.."

I've been waiting to hear that from someone else since my very first show. it was 6/24/10 Camden NJ and, although i'm a novice fan and was too young to remember any of their music during the 90s, i just remember thinking that i'd definitely heard these songs somewhere before. i just couldnt put my finger on it. and now i rarely listen to any other band. perhaps i was a fan in a former life?? haha