Having given this show a second and partial third listen, I want to upgrade my opinion to above average for Phish 3.0 (but still short of Great or Classic)

For me, YEM is upgraded to tour highlight, large sections repeatedly scale heights that are awesome, even with the flub.

And, I'll class Alaska as a song to watch. There are large portions of the LiveDownloads release where Paige's keyboards are so low in the mix that they disappear, but that is a mix issue rather than a playing issue. On the plus side, Trey's solo is excellent!