Wow, this board got ugly fast.

"Always argue like you're right, but listen like you're wrong...wisdom is developing strong opinions that are weakly held"

This review is very well written and spot on in its analysis. What's off is the conclusion that the band is now a nostalgia act, etc. Most bloggers/reviewers are way too swept away by the short term. If last night is what an "off" night is like these days, then all is well in phish world.