Friday 02/13/2015 by Lemuria

SUPERNUMERARY SHOWS: A DISCOVERY!

A "Triple Nipple" refers to any show in which Phish plays all three* of their original songs that refer to nipples**: "Fee", "Punch You in the Eye", and "The Sloth". They've been an item of amusement for decades. But even the FAQ's Triple Nipple page has until recently had the numbers wrong.

Corrected numbers reveal something that's long been elusive, partly because we didn't even know to look for it: There have only been two such shows, such that the next one will be the one, the only, Third Triple Nipple - the cubed cube, the apex of nubbin allusion, the supernumerary of supernumerary shows.

Now, knowing that there have only been two, seeing that "2" pulsating from the middle of a Venn Diagram***, may make you start to wonder, when will the Triple Nipple Trilogy be completed?

But it's not the kind of thing for which you can campaign explicitly without seeming either immature ("Tres Trip Nip, Trey?") or overly sophisticated ("I want my ternate supernumerary!") So, we're here for ya', with a solution: Special Mockingbird-supporting shirts and tanks that promote the cause without using the "n" word... or even that "s" one.

By the way, triple nipples are less common at Phish shows than on humans: Those two shows are pnlyl 0.13% (an eighth of a percent) of the 1,510 shows Phish has performed to date, much rarer than the 2% of women and 5% of men blessed (or cursed?) with a third nipple.

Methods notes:

* Some would include others songs: A nipple is mentioned in the version of "Sanity" that appears on Junta, and including "Sanity" in Triple Nipple counts increases the total to 10 - but none of the 10 versions of "Sanity" that would be counted, mentioned a nipple. The count would double again to 20 if we include "The Oh Ke Pa Ceremony," the title of which comes from a tribal ceremony painful to nipples - but the song is not clearly a nipple reference, either for Phish or as understood by most fans.

** Note that all three of these lyrical references are about nipple slicing. That's not really a methodological note, but the nubbin trouble seems weird.

*** Unlike the earlier Venn-like graph (with nested sets but aggregated numbers), numbers here are incremental. There have been 166 shows with Sloth, of which 9 also had "Fee", of which 2 also had "PYITE" - but there were only 106 shows with just "Sloth" (no PYITE), 7 with Sloth and PYITE (but no Fee), and, again, 2 with all three.

If you liked this blog post, one way you could "like" it is to make a donation to The Mockingbird Foundation, the sponsor of Phish.net. Support music education for children, and you just might change the world.


Comments

, comment by planetfour
planetfour Why does neither this post or the FAQ post actually list the 2 dates???
, comment by Lemuria
, comment by ChalkDustTeacher
ChalkDustTeacher There have been 166 shows with Sloth, of which 9 also had "Fee", of which 2 also had "PYITE" - but there were only 106 shows with just "Sloth" (no PYITE), 7 with Sloth and PYITE (but no Fee), and, again, 2 with all three.

I think you have Fee and PYITE mixed up here.
, comment by mud_lovebuddy
mud_lovebuddy As part of the %5 of males with three nipples I support this movement.
, comment by JMoney
JMoney surprisingly low number. and by the old method both were quadruple nipples.
, comment by nichobert
nichobert i wish we could think up something catchy for when they play the 3 songs that mention ghosts
, comment by HighGearAntelope
HighGearAntelope If there are 166 total Sloths... 106 + 47 + 7 + 2 = 162. You seem to be 4 short.

Also, there have been 145 PYITEs... 122 + 7 + 10 + 2 = 141. Again, 4 short.

275 Fees... but 212 + 47 + 10 + 2 = 271. Same results.

Unless I am missing something??

Glad this one is Venn, though.
, comment by benevolution
benevolution A double triple!
, comment by menoareno
menoareno I don't want to be rude, but oh kee pah ceremony is pretty unequivocally about nipple mutilation; listen to the background noises and think about the nature of the music and character of the melody. it's a tone poem that depicts what could be going through the head of a participant in this ceremony as they try to maintain their composure in a very psychedelic way. i think it's more of an allegory for confusion in general (lots of the same type of melodies you find in atr, guelah, reba, etc. but with a much cheesier, more hillbilly jazz sound). I guess it's just my opinion and it doesn't really matter and I love your graphs and charts I'm a lonely man and they help me fill the void in my life with phish trivia in a beautiful organized way
, comment by PunkDwarf
PunkDwarf How about a Leo Trio Venn diagram? Keep these things coming!
, comment by Lemuria
Lemuria @PunkDwarf said:
How about a Leo Trio Venn diagram? Keep these things coming!
It's on the list. I have 47 more in the works. Keep the ideas coming - and the feedback!
You must be logged in to post a comment.


Phish.net

Phish.net is a non-commercial project run by Phish fans and for Phish fans under the auspices of the all-volunteer, non-profit Mockingbird Foundation.

This project serves to compile, preserve, and protect encyclopedic information about Phish and their music.

Credits | Terms Of Use | Legal | DMCA

© 1990-2020  The Mockingbird Foundation, Inc. | Hosted by Linode