a Project of the Mockingbird Foundation

Performances Song History Lyrics

You Never Know

Music/Lyrics: Anastasio/Fishman/Gordon/McConnell

Debut: 2013-10-31

Historian: Tim Wade (TheEmu)

Last Update: 2014-06-12

Think of it this way: If you’re a band that has recently gained a reputation for being a nostalgia act, perhaps the ultimate musical costume is an array of new songs which look to the future instead of the past. Instead of celebrating your history, ditch the idea of re-working a classic and play an album that doesn’t yet exist. By playing potential songs from a new album, Phish found a way to simultaneously acknowledge where they’ve been and celebrate where they’re going, while confounding expectations and including the fans in a way they have never done before.

Closing the second set on 10/31/13 was “You Never Know,” the sixth of the new songs credited as a full band collaboration. The tune immediately invokes the BurgettstownLight” (listen to that version starting around 10:40) and is another example of Phish’s use of previous improvisation as the starting point for new material. Trey introduced the song as being about “a guy who stole all our money,” a likely reference to former money manager Dana Giacchetto who pled guilty to fraud charges in 2000. “You Never Know” appears to be told from the perspective of the thief, who spent some time on top of the world, but now has fallen and is being relentlessly hounded right out of the country. His “friends” aren’t going to help, and his luck seems to have run out. That is, until he comes upon two guys with “piles of cash in Mexico.” Perhaps his luck has turned again.

The music is lilting, a bouncy tune to contrast with the story of an unsavory character on the lam, and the song may be destined for type-I peaks rather than type-II vistas. It was not, however, destined for a spot on the new album. When the track list for Fuego was released, “You Never Know,” “Snow” and “Amidst the Peals of Laughter” performed on 10/31/13 were absent.

Submit notes/corrections

You must be logged in to leave a comment!



Register | Forgot Password

TwiztAround Reply
The 6/23/12 Burgettstown Light is one of my favorite moments of live Phish I've ever had the pleasure of being in the audience for. I'm glad the band realized how great of a moment that actually was and wrote a song based on that jam. Great tune!
Score: 2
JoeMoeTokyo Reply
I liked this song - the outro section is a little predicatble but still terrific. However, they might not play it ever. 2 possible reasons:

Are there potential litigation/defamation risks? Trey should not have opened his yap in the first place and he realized it too late: "I'm going to shut up now before I get myself in trouble". It seems perfectly fine and legally safe, but that doesn't mean the guy wouldn't sue and cause them headaches.

Or is it a song with a message of moderation and not partying too hard and financial concerns that would not go over well with a Phish crowd lost in revelry. Who wants to be reminded about these topics in the middle of Phish show?
Score: 0
phaedrus Reply
phaedrus I could see this drop into What's The Use?, but it might just be Trey hitting that note as he's talking to the crowd, closing the set.
Score: 0
AndrewGrey42 Reply
AndrewGrey42 Awesome write up! <3
Score: 0
drewy1215 Reply
Call me crazy, but does anyone hear this teased in the beginning of the Hartford Tweezer jam? Mike does the baseline and Page and Trey follow briefly...
Score: 0
Login Register