Roses Are Free
Original Artist: Ween
Original Album: Chocolate and Cheese (1994)
Albums: Hampton Comes Alive
Historian: Phillip Zerbo (pzerbo)
Last Update: 2012-07-28
Phish interpreted this typically bizarre Ween song, retaining much of the feel of the original while adapting it seamlessly to their own constantly evolving sound. While some fans may have thought this to be an unusual cover choice, “Roses” simply represents yet another hue in a stylistic palette as rich and colorful as the spectrum of light itself.
Ween, "Roses Are Free" – Live from Bonnaroo 2002
After its premiere on the fall 1997 tour, Phish wasted no time employing “Roses” as a vital improvisational vehicle. Most notable is the 27-minute version on 4/3/98, which featured a phenomenal jam of multiple, subtle layers that remains a quintessential statement of Phish jamming. Combine that with outstanding versions on 12/31/97 (in the middle of rocking “Mike’s Groove”) and 7/13/99 (leading into the first "NO2" in five years), and your collection is nearly complete. Be sure to pick up the 12/11/97 debut that segued out of a kick-ass “Drowned” jam, which is featured in Bittersweet Motel, including snippets of the song's pre-show backstage run-through. No collection of “Roses” would be complete without the "good..... MORning!" 35-minute pre-dawn monster from The Show on 12/31/99.
Phish, "Roses Are Free" – 4/3/98, Uniondale, NY (Part 1)
Phish, "Roses Are Free" – 4/3/98, Uniondale, NY (Part 2)
"Roses" would make only four appearances on the Phish stage over the subsequent decade (see especially 10/1/00 and 6/25/04) but then return to regular rotation in 2010, including appearances among the pristine mountains of Telluride on 8/10/10, during the opening set of the Halloween festivities on 10/31/10 in Atlantic City, and evolving out of “Piper” in the Polo Field of San Francisco’s Golden Gate Park on 8/12/11. While still appreciated and a fan-favorite cover tune, with these more recent offerings the band is seemingly content with concise renditions compared to the distinctive and exploratory versions from the '90s. That said, check out the excellent 6/8/12 Worcester rendition where the band offers a glimpse of the song’s former improvisational glory.
Phish, "Roses Are Free" – 6/8/12, Worcester, MA
In an amusing side note, at Ween’s 8/4/99 Seattle concert, Gene Ween introduced their own “Roses” by noting Phish’s cover of the tune, and that they started playing it again in order to “reclaim it.”