Having been to 6 of the 10, my crew in its various forms (we have a core 3 together for 20 years, have escalated to 20 at times, which is quite frankly a roving shxt show) have debated this on and off since The Went (our first.) If you ignore the scene/vibe then the only thing I would dispute is Coventry ranking so high. Sure, it was ph ish. Musically when they bomb, still better than 95% of the music world. However, compared to themselves, Coventry was overall rubbish. The flubs seemed intentional at the beginning, then it was just painful. This wasnt every song. It wasnt always the entire song. But after hearing so many years of spectacular music, and spending last weekend shaking my head at just how amazing they have played of late, I simply can not rank Coventry that high. I am happy to let time and space marinate Magnaball for the larger population, but even 20 years later i am confident Magnaball will rank higher than Coventry. On music.