There's plenty of room on this site to share your opinions about Phish. If you want to start a thread on the forum to do a little armchair quarterbacking of last night's show have at it. But I wish these recaps would focus on descriptions of the music rather than opinion. Some opinion is unavoidable, sure, and I do wanna know which parts of the show you like and dislike. But I also would like a little more meat about what the show sounded like. Maybe I'm old school. I used to read recaps in the days when we traded tapes. And back then you relied on the reviews to decide which tapes you wanted to seek out. A review that just gave you the writer's opinion of how the show shoulda gone wasn't much help in finding the shows you wanted. All it could show you was how that particular guy was underwhelmed.
With that said, I do agree with your estimation of the show. Although I thought Caspian was above average last night and the Tweezer was cool, Gorge Night 2 will not make it into my 2011 highlights folder.