I was actually at this show, although I thought it was earlier than 1989. There weren't many people there, but it was definitely rocking. I had never heard the band before so any Phish songs were unknown to me. They definitely played Fire by Jimi Hendrix and Good Times, Bad Times.
Dartmouth College, Hanover, NH
No known setlist!
This show was part of the "1989 Tour."
This show was a great one. The band played in the main living room at The Tabard, a co-ed house, on Dartmouth's fraternity row. I don't have a setlist, but know for sure that Sanity was played. It was a rocking trippy two set show and had many of the tunes that were typical of the band's repertoire at that time. I am not even sure Paul was there taping that night, as I have never seen a copy of this show in circulation. Any leads would be wonderful.