- Recent
- Shows
-
Music
- Song Histories
- Discography
- The Man Who Stepped Into Yesterday
- Dinner and a Movie Episodes
- Charts
- Jam Charts
- A Cappella Chart
- Bustout Chart
- Debut Chart
- Guest Chart
- LivePhish Tracks Chart
- Makisupa Keyword Chart
- Narration Chart
- Secret Language Language Chart
- Song Totals Chart
- Tease Chart
- Tease Timings
- Tour/Show Openers Chart
- 20+ Minute Jam Chart
- Longest Versions Chart
- Acoustic Trey Chart
- Side Project 20+ Min Jam Chart
- Side Project Debuts
- Community
- .Net
- Login
- Register
- Store
Permalink for Comment #1313681512 by _rrot_
Support Phish.net & Mbird
Phish.net is a project of the non-profit Mockingbird Foundation.
Recent Blog Posts
Phish Studies Conference Unveils 2024 Agenda, Sphere PhanArt Event 2024-04-17
Attendance Bias Podcast Revisits Phil Lesh And Phriends At The Warfield, April 15-16-17, 1999 2024-04-15
Surrender To The Flow #82: Las Vegas 2024 2024-04-12
PhishNet Was Born June 22, 1991 2024-03-18
Divided Sky Foundation Announces 2024 Fun(d) Run and Music Fest 2024-03-12
This Time Will Be Different: Attendance Bias Podcast Celebrates 15 Years Since Hampton 2009 2024-03-01
REPRISE Phish Tribute Debut Streaming Free from Nectar's 2024-02-29
Mexico4 Recap: Meet The New Phish, Same As The Old Phish 2024-02-25
Mexico3 Recap: Then Came the Sound 2024-02-24
Mexico2 Recap: Never-ending Wave of Hope 2024-02-23
Attendance Bias Podcast Revisits Phil Lesh And Phriends At The Warfield, April 15-16-17, 1999 2024-04-15
Surrender To The Flow #82: Las Vegas 2024 2024-04-12
PhishNet Was Born June 22, 1991 2024-03-18
Divided Sky Foundation Announces 2024 Fun(d) Run and Music Fest 2024-03-12
This Time Will Be Different: Attendance Bias Podcast Celebrates 15 Years Since Hampton 2009 2024-03-01
REPRISE Phish Tribute Debut Streaming Free from Nectar's 2024-02-29
Mexico4 Recap: Meet The New Phish, Same As The Old Phish 2024-02-25
Mexico3 Recap: Then Came the Sound 2024-02-24
Mexico2 Recap: Never-ending Wave of Hope 2024-02-23
Phish.net
The Mockingbird Foundation
What a red herring. This is a typical BS method of argument -- so typical there's a name for it: "The notion that songs need to be stretched out for twenty and even thirty to forty minutes to be successful is simply" a Straw Man.
Need? 20, 30, 40? I haven't heard folks saying that, so what's the point of pretending they are?
The "jaded vets" want jams, not durations.
But if you think we're all size queens, fine.