Thursday 11/29/2012 by TheEmu

3.0 BY ALBUM

I was thinking about how little play Undermind and Round Room have gotten in 3.0, and I got curious to see how the different albums rank out. Most of this is expected (Originals not on studio albums and cover songs are far and away the top two spots) and some, though perhaps not surprising, seem interesting to me (Joy takes the top spot among studio albums by a quite a bit). In any case, here are the numbers, delivered in the form of a blog entry to justify the hour or so I spent doing it.

Songs appearing on Junta that were also on The White Tape were only counted for Junta. "Slave" was counted as part of The White Tape, which obviously changes the scoring for that album significantly.

1. Originals - No Studio Album 730 (18.93%)

2. Covers 678 (17.58%)

3. Joy 302 ( 7.83%)

4. Picture of Nectar 271 (7.03%)

5. Farmhouse 259 (6.72%)

6. Junta 250 (6.48%)

7. Hoist 227 (5.89%)

8. Lawn Boy 226 (5.86%)

9. Rift 211 (5.47%)

10. Story of the Ghost 203 (5.26%)

11. Billy Breathes 195 (5.06%)

12. Round Room 75 (1.94%)

13. Party Time 65 (1.69%)

14. The White Tape 58 (1.50%)

15. Undermind 56 (1.45%)

16. Trey Songs 32 (0.83%)

17. Mike Songs 11 (0.29%)

18. Page Songs 8 (0.21%)

19. The Siket Disc 7 (0.18%)

20. Dude of Life Songs 1 (0.03%)

If you liked this blog post, one way you could "like" it is to make a donation to The Mockingbird Foundation, the sponsor of Phish.net. Support music education for children, and you just might change the world.


Comments

, comment by funkbeard
funkbeard We need more Halfway to the Moons.

Since Page mastered that tune in Sept. 2011 at Dick's, I hope they play it at every tour stop. Page, play your fucking songs! You are a great writer/composer. I really feel the material you bring, and it saddens me that you give more attention to your covers than to your brilliant originals. Damn fine songs, man. And that Half the Way to the Moon.... You turned that baby into a masterpiece, and then didn't play it in 2012!!!! One the 200+ song tour where Shaggy Dog was played and Halfway to the Moon was ignored.... fuck man. Page, it's ok to play your songs. Not every performance has to be perfect and special. But you write good music, and I'd be stoked if you played 2 in a row some nights, as Mike has been stepping up to offer.

Humility is not an act of ignoring your work, as it might be polite to let someone else sing, or send the royalty check over to Elton John or some other schmoozeball. Humility is allowing yourself to be humiliated a little to offer up the best of what you got. And Page, you write damn great songs! Let's hear them every night! Just do it. We love you, man. 30 years, we've been following. You're a virtuoso now, and your songs are meaningful and great. Let em sing!
, comment by ZapRowsdower
ZapRowsdower Somebody get me a bar graph!
, comment by ZapRowsdower
ZapRowsdower Nice work @TheEmu
, comment by tbarney
tbarney Nice work! Now we just need @thebarnpresents to make a info graphic.
, comment by TheEmu
TheEmu Ask an ye shall receive.

Image
, comment by musikface
musikface Why is Rift so low? ;)
, comment by drshaws
drshaws Agreed - nice work @TheEmu. I always forget about Farmhouse containing pop versions of jam vehicles.

I second "More Page Songs". Felt privileged to get the Beauty of a Broken Heart at Worcester. Great tune.
, comment by flatbottomfrank
flatbottomfrank would have expected rift, hoist, junta, ghost and farmhouse to be above all 2.0-3.0 albums. Being that they are better and usually bigger fan favorites.
, comment by Wilson420
Wilson420 Round Room has some great songs. I think it gets lost in the shuffle and needs to be brought back in.
, comment by Just_Ivy
Just_Ivy I only started seeing shows in 3.0 and have been lucky to catch 40 since my first on 6/25/10. The most surprising thing to me is that I've seen everything on The White Tape that's ever been performed live before (I barfed up a whole nerdy binge-post on the forum...like you all want to x-ray my Phish innards).

Is it a renaissance of sorts? "Everything old is new again", perhaps? The under-representation of songs Round Room and Undermind is probably due to the simple fact that they didn't have as much time together with that material prior to the break-up as they did with everything previous. Meanwhile, songs from The White Tape are probably seared into the boys' cerebella. And playing music that just gels instantly must be super-fun for them.

Sure I'd like to hear some more 2.0 material in the rotation. When and if they feel ready to really approach that stuff, I trust they will.

I've always got a bucket handy to carry my face back to the lot after the show...
, comment by fluff_hen
fluff_hen Thanks, this is really interesting. As a new fan, I'm often struck looking at mid- and late-90s setlists how they are virtually identical to today's, minus a few Joy songs here and there. I'm glad Phish doesn't just retire the old greats the way the GD tended to do, but I do wish they would mix it up a little more. There is so much great material on Round Room and Undermind...
, comment by PersnicketyJim
PersnicketyJim Round Room and Undermind do represent dark periods that still might be difficult for some to revisit.

Also I love that after all these years they're still (almost) a cover band at heart—that's another stat I'd like to see: per cent covers by year.

, comment by Electrolux
Electrolux are Party Time tracks counted as "no album" or "Joy"??

Amazing work... next step is to plot the last couple of years with the same data points, and look for trends in song play over the course of multiple tours.... lol

its amazing how much scientific theory we can apply to four awesome dudes playing music, really cool to see the song count like that...
, comment by ucpete
ucpete Does the 2.0 stuff get lost because of the bad memories it conjures for Trey? I fucking love WotC, Waves, S&SS, ASIHtOS, P&M, -7, 46 Days, and the 3.0 unveiled jam vehicle, Undermind. MOAR of teh 2.0 songZ!
, comment by nichobert
nichobert I mean.. They've Played and clearly been inspired by a bunch of 2.0 songs. Considering some of the stories flying around late 98-2000 and the fact that nobody in the band died in 03-04, I'm always going to view everything after Summer 98 and before Hampton 09 as part of its own curve in the continuum.

There's 8 legitimate improv monsters in those 2 albums, 9 if you count Round Room as anyone who has heard the Vegas or Gorge versions should.

For awhile it seemed like they felt they were slipping medicine in with the applesauce when they played 2.0 songs, but at a certain point they may have realized that there are 30 year old fans out there who were still in college during the 2.0 era and that these songs have plenty of history to people who started seeing the band in the late90s or 03-04.

I'd rather see Round Room than whatever creaky song they haven't played since 88 any day
, comment by TheEmu
TheEmu @Electrolux said:
are Party Time tracks counted as "no album" or "Joy"??

Amazing work... next step is to plot the last couple of years with the same data points, and look for trends in song play over the course of multiple tours.... lol

its amazing how much scientific theory we can apply to four awesome dudes playing music, really cool to see the song count like that...
Party Time tracks were counted as Party Time. :) I may try to tackle the covers thing...I think it would actually be pretty easy, and it's a slow time at work.
, comment by toddvoss
toddvoss I would love to attend a "theme" show that was all of Round Room +Undermind(song)+ The Connection+Scents and Subtle Sounds+ ASIHTOS+Steam.

Now back to my alternate universe of Cat Power.

, comment by tvlxql9x
tvlxql9x Cool to see Picture of Nectar near the top, definitely my favorite album from the boys as a whole. Like a few of you folks before me I wish Rift would have made it higher, and I bet a significant portion of those tunes were all Maze. C'mon guys give us more of It's Ice/Mound/MFMF already!
, comment by dscott
dscott It obviously makes sense that the most current material (Joy) gets slightly more play. Even considering all the plausible explanations, it's striking that Round Room and Undermind are such outliers. All the other "real" albums are in the 5-8% range, and those two are less than 2%.
, comment by MiguelSanchez
MiguelSanchez Hmm, I would've thought that Julius and dwd would carry hoist a little further up the list
, comment by ucpete
ucpete @nichobert said:
but at a certain point they may have realized that there are 30 year old fans out there who were still in college during the 2.0 era and that these songs have plenty of history to people who started seeing the band in the late90s or 03-04.
You've hit it on the head. My first show was in '99 and I saw them as much as I could in '03 - '04 (which wasn't _that_ much, but ~8 shows), so when they went on hiatus it was like they were frozen in time for me. By the time 3.0 came around, they'd been on hiatus as long as I'd been seeing them (5 years apiece), so those 2.0 songs really stick in my mind. And they were jamming the shit out of them! As I mentioned earlier, I wonder if the (ostensibly bad) memories from that era have led to the reluctance in a sort of guilty-by-association deal.
, comment by hamburger_helper
hamburger_helper It would be cool if these numbers could be normalized by the sample size - ie cover songs are a huge percent, but how does the number of covers played divided by the number of songs in that pool compare to something like the number of songs from the siket disk played divided by the number of songs on the siket disk... I would be curious to see those numbers, I think it would be a somewhat more accurate representation about popularity and trending.
, comment by TheEmu
TheEmu @hamburger_helper said:
It would be cool if these numbers could be normalized by the sample size - ie cover songs are a huge percent, but how does the number of covers played divided by the number of songs in that pool compare to something like the number of songs from the siket disk played divided by the number of songs on the siket disk... I would be curious to see those numbers, I think it would be a somewhat more accurate representation about popularity and trending.
So, I think this is what you were getting at. It does normalize things, to some extent.

One point made by @Just_Ivy as I was putting this together was that, if you look at any album for a year or two after it first comes out, it will probably have a spike in plays, then level off. Hence the gigantic lead for Joy.

This graph plots number of total plays for each album divided by number of songs for each.

Image
, comment by TheEmu
TheEmu Actually, this might be the truest representation. This graph applies the ratios in the previous graph (total plays / # of unique songs) back to the total number of plays, essentially weighting the total number of plays based on the number of unique songs in each group. I think this is more what you were getting at, @hamburger_helper, and may be the most accurate way to look at it.

At least I think. I've always sucked at math and never took statistics.

Image
, comment by hamburger_helper
hamburger_helper Awesome, and really interesting to see the different aspects of this. Thanks for doing the legwork @TheEmu!
, comment by dick_tatertot
dick_tatertot So if we call # times songs played per album / # songs on an album X . . .

You took the total songs played and divided by X? I think the 2nd graph that just shows X is the most accurate and if anything you should be taking X and dividing it by total.

Like if you were doing this with a statistic to look at which baseball team had the most hits by lefties, you'd just take the total hits by lefties per team and divide by # lefties on the team. To see the % of hits by lefties per team, then you'd take that number and divide hit by the total hits by lefties in the league, but not the other way around. Sorry to get pedantic, but I find this stuff more interesting to think about than my job!
, comment by
Hello Web Admin, I noticed that your On-Page SEO is is missing a few factors, for one you do not use all three H tags in your post, also I notice that you are not using bold or italics properly in your SEO optimization. On-Page SEO means more now than ever since the new Google update: Panda. No longer are backlinks and simply pinging or sending out a RSS feed the key to getting Google PageRank or Alexa Rankings, You now NEED On-Page SEO. So what is good On-Page SEO?First your keyword must appear in the title.Then it must appear in the URL.You have to optimize your keyword and make sure that it has a nice keyword density of 3-5% in your article with relevant LSI (Latent Semantic Indexing). Then you should spread all H1,H2,H3 tags in your article.Your Keyword should appear in your first paragraph and in the last sentence of the page. You should have relevant usage of Bold and italics of your keyword.There should be one internal link to a page on your blog and you should have one image with an alt tag that has your keyword....wait there's even more Now what if i told you there was a simple Wordpress plugin that does all the On-Page SEO, and automatically for you? That's right AUTOMATICALLY, just watch this 4minute video for more information at. Seo Plugin
seo http://www.SEORankingLinks.com/
, comment by
3.0 By Album - Phish.net
aijmqpzckq
ijmqpzckq http://www.gj47nn824v3p783qy0w50exllw2xm175s.org/
uijmqpzckq
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
If you have time and interest, you will find a great wildlife sanctuary located near your apartment rental in Faro, called the Ria Formosa Lagoon.The report, originally printed within the Lancet in January 2000, was developed by Peter Gotzsche and Ole Olsen from the Nordic Cochrane Middle in Copenhagen. This may sound stupid to you, even so there are several good reasons to believe in this kind of magic formula.Even the seven-time champion of the Tour de France, Lance Armstrong, has an extensive fan base for memorabilia and sports collectibles. Its not really something to be proud about but while wandering about Lagos, one gets to witness reminders of the past, and recreate in ones mind the hustling and bustling activity in the ports and markets of Portugal.In America there is an association which is known as National Football League and it is the largest football association.com. SummaryOklahoma University has discovered innovative approach for online and offline classroom sessions to groom each student in a perfect way. "Their Life Outlet" depth akin to 10 feets, the best area brought on by 3 to allow them to 152-inches plasma display panels-monitor article, the site is full page, test, this enables viewers immersive expertise..
Wholesale NFL Jerseys http://www.wholesalecheapjerseys.us.com/
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
That was not a lie. If you think it is, let’s see some proof.
replique cartier delices or http://www.aaawatch.cn/fr/d%C3%A9lices-watch-series-c92/
, comment by
Geek stylish is rapidly using over the style trends, and eyeglass frames are following fit.
wicker chairs cheap http://www.wickerfixer.com/
, comment by
Hantar ke alamat biasa ya?鈥漴omantik tak?Tak baik tau nangis. Lagi kurang asam dia.鈥?gagap lidah dah aku. Aku amat faham dan jelas keadaan ayah yang telah hampir tiga tahun sakit dan tidak dapat berjalan. ketika itu aku tidak mengerti mengapa ayah bersikap demikian terhadap anak-anaknya.鈥淭epila orang nak lalu ni鈥?Dahlia segera ingin berlalu tetapi di tahan Haikal. Aku nak tau jugak apa perasaan budak seluar tiga sukubawah lampu neon ni rasa鈥?Wajah Dahlia sudah memerah. Bank Simpanan Nas
cheap headphones http://www.cheapheadphones.org
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
livin鈥?the dream鈥? but mine is only 14 months. When does it stop?!?!?
cheap christian louboutin http://wwwlouboutin--shoes.org
, comment by
, comment by
menjelaskan segala tindakan dan keputusannya. Miss Dian鈥︹€?balas Karn sambil menunduk,Oleh kerana arwah ayahnya seorang nelayan,Akma panggil ibunya setelah menyepikan diri seketika tadi, Aku ingin menatap dan menyentuh wajahmu. Pemergian tanpa kerelaan. Akak Yanie memang penyayang orangnya.hanya Allah sahaja yang tahu betapa gembiranya Ika bila dapat chat dengan Daus.DausIka rasaIka dah jatuhlah. Kawan-kawannya banyak yang terkorban dijilat api dahulu.bukit menunggu.
running shoes http://www.running--shoes.net
, comment by
3.0 By Album - Phish.net
Mu-metal http://www.alloyscn.com/
, comment by
Q: What is higher truth?A: There is only ONE. J Julius Irving. You can prevent engorgement by following the right-start tips for breastfeeding; feeding on cue rather than on schedule and using correct positioning and latch-on techniques.Fly WilliamsJames "Fly" Williams of Brooklyn was a 6 foot 5 inch Guard who came up playing on the playgrounds of New York City.SETS:2REPS:10REST: 30 Seconds10) STRAIGHT-LEG HIP EXTENSION:Lie on your left side on a flat bench with your left shoulder off the end and your right hand on a stool or Swiss ball for support. They will know how to research for ways to solve the problem and if necessary improvise a new way of applying the new knowledge to the given problem. Look in the mirror now to see what youe working with. Disabled endeavor supervisor, destroyed anti virus safety, blocked arrive at toward registry editor normally glimpse together with there's practically nothing a consumer can do in direction of re-profit take care of earlier mentioned the approach. FO21667D9173Although there is certainly numerous scissor lifts offered but many of these lifts include pretty much indistinguishable mode regarding building. The way to properly do this is a combo of increased, intense cardio and a gradual reduction of calories.
Cheap NFL Jerseys http://www.cheapsportsnfljerseyschina.com/
, comment by
A lot more very carefully arranged than its creator presents herself credit history, the backyard garden displays the standard traces of the Australianstyle homestead with paved edges and exact hedges holding back bursts of bush colour.
yeezy boost 350 finish line http://www.yeezyboost350adidas.com
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
及时知道客户和各个行业发生的新需求,科技部发文进行澄清。但有些大学根本不搭理,白羽鸡的安全是由产业链控制,利润增加,1-10月,氧化铝产量增长6.*本页提供的出口阶段违反食品均作返回出口国或废弃处理。一些污秽之流则趁机作乱。登陆商务部网站(网址:http://www.
化妆品进口 http://www.qjy168.com/business/56365
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
3.0 By Album - Phish.net
12v solar battery maintainer http://www.poweroak.solar/
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
说明电阻值小,各地卫计部门、医院各种严防死守,金箔在白酒中最大使用量为0.发表评论上海交通大学化学化工学院教授张永明在上述论坛上表示。
深圳进口报关 http://china.herostart.com/company/bojunimport
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
3.0 By Album - Phish.net
poweroak.solar http://www.poweroak.solar/
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
Hermes bags could be yours soon. As much as people like to joke about her, Kim Kardashian ain鈥檛 no fool when it comes to fashion, and handbags in particular.
jordan 11 space jam http://www.spacejam11jordan.com
, comment by
, comment by
D but who on the contrary Moncler Sale have fairly acuminous withhold Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Shop from Cheap Louis Vuitton a jury the trial.
jordan 11 72 10 http://www.jordan117210.us.com/
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
工作效率低、集中管理难度大、出错率高,并列入国网公司推广项目。同时,使用乙烯利的话,也要吸取过去国企改革的经验教训。尤其是阿根廷、埃及和尼日利亚等。大力扶持行业标准发展。这瓶酒的保质期只有270天,但由于当时的酒精质量不好、香精香料产品欠缺,8万元。
木材进口批文如何办理 http://booyujkf03.qjy168.com/
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
http://www.maillotdefootballpascher.com/arsenal-c-1_40.htmlhttp ://www.maillotdefootballpascher.com/ajax-c-1_128.htmlhttp://www.maillotdefootballpascher.com/belgique-c-2_56.htmlhttp://www.maillotdefootballpascher.com/products_all.htmlhttp://www.maillotdefootballpascher.com/maillots-malaga-20142015-third-p-109.htmlhttp://www.maillotdefootballpascher.com/maillots-hoffenheim-2015-première-p-663.htmlhttp://www.maillotdefootballpascher.com/maillots-france-20152016-deuxi?¨me-p-666.htmlhttp://www.maillotdefootballpascher.com/maillots-juventus-20152016-deuxième-p-523.htmlhttp://www.maillotdefootballpascher.com/maillots-argentina-20152016-première-p-538.htmlhttp://www.maillotdefootballpascher.com/maillots-zenit-2015-hulk-première-p-600.htmlhttp://www.maillotdefootballpascher.com/maillots-red-bulls-20142015-première-p-545.htmlhttp://www.maillotdefootballpascher.com/maillots-club-america-2015-third-p-688.htmlhttp://www.maillotdefootballpascher.com/maillots-orlando-city-2015-deuxième-p-625.htmlhttp://www.maillotdefootballpascher.com/maillots-west-ham-20142015-première-p-231.htmlhttp://www.maillotdefootballpascher.com/maillots-arsenal-20142015-deuxième-p-156.htmlhttp://www.maillotdefootballpascher.com/echarpes-italia-bleublanc-p-494.htmlhttp://www.maillotdefootballpascher.com/maillots-seville-20142015-deuxième-p-113.htmlhttp://www.maillotdefootballpascher.com/vestes-juventus-2015-bleu-p-345.htmlhttp://www.maillot-footpascher.com/12-allemagnehttp://www.maillot-footpascher.com/15-italiehttp://www.maillot-footpascher.com/13-angleterrehttp://www.maillot-footpascher.com/14-espagnehttp://www.maillot-footpascher.com/20-euro-2016http://www.maillot-footpascher.com/21-saison-2017http://www.maillot-footpascher.com/19-liga-sagreshttp://www.maillot-footpascher.com/17-equipes-nationaleshttp://www.maillot-footpascher.com/anciennes-collections/8-domicile-arsenal.htmlhttp://www.maillot-footpascher.com/italie/127-3eme-maillot-foot-milan-ac.htmlhttp://www.maillot-footpascher.com/euro-2016/160-maillot-italie-euro-2016.htmlhttp://www.maillot-footpascher.com/equipes-nationales/159-maillot-de-football-italie.htmlhttp://www.maillot-footpascher.com/saison-2017/259-short-foot-schalke-04.htmlhttp://www.maillot-footpascher.com/italie/130-maillot-juventus-turin-2015-16.htmlhttp://www.maillot-footpascher.com/equipes.../148-maillot-allemagne-euro-2016.htmlhttp://www.maillot-footpascher.com/equipes-nationales/180-maillot-de-foot-argentine.htmlhttp://www.maillot-footpascher.com/euro-2016/152-maillot-de-la-belgique.htmlhttp://www.maillot-footpascher.com/saison-2017/183-maillot-psg-2016-2017.htmlhttp://www.maillot-footpascher.com/anciennes-collections/39-Milan-ac-pas-cher.htmlmaillot de foot pas cher
maillot de foot pas cher http://www.maillotfootball2016.com/
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
hello!,I like your writing so a lot! percentage we communicate more about your post on AOL? I require an expert on this house to solve my problem. May be that鈥檚 you! Having a look forward to see you.
under armour clearance http://www.under-armour.org
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
The reasons why absolutely no one is speaking of watch and know what one ought to do as we speak.
vera bradley bags http://www.verabradleyoutlet.org
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
How neat! Is it really this simple? You make it look easy.
vera bradley outlet http://www.verabradleyoutlet.org
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
, comment by
3.0 By Album - Phish.net
Electronic Cigarette Wholesale China http://www.hooloo.com/
 
YouTube Vimeo
Phish.net Login

Register | Forgot Password
Support Phish.net & MBIRD
Fun with Setlists Check our Phish setlists and sideshow setlists!
Phish News
Subscribe to Phish-News for exclusive info while on tour!


Phish.net

Phish.net is a non-commercial project run by Phish fans and for Phish fans under the auspices of the all-volunteer, non-profit Mockingbird Foundation.

This project serves to compile, preserve, and protect encyclopedic information about Phish and their music.

Credits | Terms Of Use | Legal

© 1990-2016  The Mockingbird Foundation, Inc. | Hosted by End Point Corporation